LOGIN PANEL :

Displaying Reviews for
Forgiveness

Total Reviews: 23

View chapters for a specific chapter:

jump   | next >>
q.thews
Signed | Chapter : 1 | Date : 10/09/09
A very nice series of one shot, i would really like (but i'm not really asking for) some other POVs, like Fred's, Angelina's, Molly's and Arthur's. Strangely the most i'm interested in would be Angelina's as it would be a little an external POV, while the others would be more "obvious" and expected.
Ciao!
Author Feedback: Interesting idea you have there, I may play with that a bit. Thanks!
 

cosmopolitan411
Signed | Chapter : 1 | Date : 14/07/09
this was an interesting one, breaking from the pattern interms of he monologue and then scene, instead only bringing in moments of scenes/quotes into the diatribe... my one thing, however, is that you didn't change the tone with ron as much... he had his story, his emotions, all of it... just not his own voice

does that make any sense at all? gah, forget me, i'm pissing on about bs over an amazing piece



point is, KUDOS!
Author Feedback: Ron's piece was actually harder to write as we knew exactly what had happened already I wanted to show the rawness of his emotions but I'm not quite sure I managed it. Honestly I think this final installment fell short a little. And your saying Ron didn't have his own voice kind of makes sense... hmmm... thanks for that.
 

cakeandmilk
Signed | Chapter : 1 | Date : 22/06/09
Aw, Ron’s matured. I love that part of the story. It’s a bit predictable since Ron is their bestfriend and he wouldn’t not forgive them but somehow it’s different because how you made Ron so mature beyond his years to accept such crumbling fate that could be bestowed on a man. I am so proud of Ron and that won’t change! But this fic made it all too easy for me to say that Ron had climbed up the ladder from being the bloke who has the ‘emotional range of a teaspoon’ to a ‘true and loyal best friend’.

Congratulations, I love the story. I’ve read the other ones prior to this fic and I love them as well. You described their feelings and emotions quite vividly and that’s what I like about writers. The words could drive a stake through your heart and being. That what the character feels; the reader feels them as well. Nicely done!
Author Feedback: I really did seem to hit home with this one as your description of what Ron went through and his response was exactly what I was aiming for.

Your description of the skill of writers and your classing me among those who possess such genius, humbles me greatly.

Thank you.
 

Mai_Dreizehn
Signed | Chapter : 1 | Date : 16/06/09
well. i kinda feel sorry for him. assumed too much i suppose. that and the fact that his mother's molly, who i think is a very pushy person based on what i have read in the books.

i completely agree with the reason of his forgiveness of harry and hermione. abandoning one's friend for the nth time, mostly when said friend truly needed him is just so... i can't even describe it. 'tis karma, i suppose.

very beautiful piece. kinda refreshing to read something about a ron-hermione wedding engagement gone awry that is very realistic and not cliche.
Author Feedback: You do kind of feel sorry for Ron and Ginny in this series, its awful to go through a break up under normal circumstances but when you have indeed assumed too much about what and how a person feels about and towards you, you kind of open yourself to whatever comes.

I am glad you enjoyed the piece. I felt like it had to be realistic to convey the depth of the situation, I'm glad you agree.
 

ladylaughalot
Signed | Chapter : 1 | Date : 13/06/09
Ron should have found someone else as should have Ginny. Still a beautifully written installment. Well done.
Author Feedback: I didn't mean to write it as though they are not out meeting other people and dating and moving on because in my mind they are... they have to Harry and Hermione have clearly moved on. But in that reflective moment when they think back on things that are seeing what they should have acknowledged a long time ago.

Glad you like it though!
 

apaidan
Signed | Chapter : 1 | Date : 12/06/09
First, let me say that it's an excellent chapter and it brings things about very well.

Ron finally grows up through this travail, and we see that as he starts from the perspective of having survived. 'falls flat' isn't the term I would use, but there is something missing. At least for me.

I was expecting a crowning moment of 'Ronness' if you will, between the time Hermione hits him with the fact that she loves Harry and he crawls into the bottle. The previous three stories limit this to something offstage from them, I realize, but I was expecting something more Ron than one unspoken parting shot at Harry as he left to be with their friend.

But, it's a very good look at Ron's journey to maturity. I like how this weaves the other three stories together and the entire thing is a whole. Some of hte other reviewers have mentioned one more look at the entire process from someone outside the quartet. That could be intersting, there are several potential candidates for that job.

Luna, the perpetual outsider. Minerva who observed them all in school and, most likely, afterwards as well. Neville, another example of someone on the outside but still privy to the relationship between them. Molly might be a good choice, she seems to have accepted the reality of Harry and Hermione by the time Ginny's tale came around. Or Arthur. Who never says much, but observes more than folks give him credit for. Somehow, I can't picture him being overly surprised that night. Dismayed at how it occurred. In pain for the pain his children were going through, but not surprised in the least.

Again, another excellent addition to this story. Pay no attention to my ramblings about Ron, the story works well as it is.

apAidan
Author Feedback: Funny that you should mention a moment of 'Ronness' where he confronted Harry on his visit to the Burrow but it felt forced to me so I abandoned it in favor of placing more emphasis on Hermione's letter. True it was more subtle but in the end Ron's issue is with Hermione because she chose Harry in the face of knowing that Harry was with Ginny. I suppose I should have pointed that out, then maybe it would have been a bit clearer.

I have been mulling over the outside view idea and my choice had been Luna when I considered it. But I was intrigued by your other suggestions as well, particularly Arthur. As you said Arthur is extremely perceptive but seldom voices his opinions, the complete antithesis of Molly. I think there is some possibility there.

As always I thank you for your sincerely heartfelt comments.

Until next time... happy reading.
 

saleth
Unsigned | Chapter : 1 | Date : 12/06/09
Well it was a nice chapter, the idea of forgiveness being essential to be capable of love is quite right.
I thought too that it was lacking a little bit, but mostly at the end, I would have liked a better conclusion or something, but still it was a good chapter, so thanks for writing all this series!
Author Feedback: I've tried and failed with a different ending so for now I will leave it be. I'm glad you enjoyed the series.
 

gingercat
Signed | Chapter : 1 | Date : 12/06/09
Bravo to you....another outstanding story. This series was very "TRUE" to life. My only problem was with Hermione blurting out that she loves Harry....in front of all those people. She could have done a little better to save face for Ron. Saying that....it does NOT take anything away from the story. I am glad Hermione sent Ron the note, she needed to give him some closure. I have always liked Ron, just not with Hermione. Having Harry deliver the invitation and what he said was just PERFECT....he didn't apologize for loving her, just that loving her hurt his best friend.

I love Harry as "Daddy"....he has so much love to give, and he is very capable of taking care of his family.

Very nice series. I always enjoy your stories and I look forward to many more.
Author Feedback: I thought about having Hermione pull Ron aside and tell him or having her not exactly say she was in love with Harry but I felt like Rowling in the sense that it would take something really big to bring Harry and Hermione together. Rowling has always said that Harry and Ron fought the troll because considering how this had begun with Hermione it would take a dramatic life changing event to make them all friends. I felt the same way with this piece. A shouted declaration like that in the middle of a rehearsal dinner... I didn't think it could get much bigger.

I am glad that you enjoyed the series and thanks for being such a faithful reader.
 

Locke
Signed | Chapter : 1 | Date : 11/06/09
Understanding and forgiving are not adjectives oft used to describe Ron, but they fit in perfectly with the rest of this short, wonderful series. A pretty good endnote piece in my opinion. I think the reason why it might have fell a little flat is the first piece. It does not go into the detail or emotion that the other pieces in the series do.
Author Feedback: I hadn't thought of the first piece as less emotional than the others. Perhaps if I read them in succession I will pick up on what you are suggesting. Still I am pleased with how the series turned out and I am equally pleased that you have enjoyed it as well.
 

Looney Warner Mouse.
Unsigned | Chapter : 1 | Date : 11/06/09
Wonderful Short story.
I like how you did Ron in this story.
you really out did your self again.
I am looking to the next story that you come up with.
You make my day!
Please continue with your excellent work.
Ron came up to me and said.
Ron" Finley a story about me"
Harry" Good for you Ron"
Looney Warner Mouse " Better him then me right Harry"
Harry" Right Looney "
Hermione" I hope that the next story is about you Harry and My self soon"
Plucky Duck " Don't conut on it"
Buster Bunny " En what's up Duck!"
and Anvil fell on Plucky Duck.
Babs Bunny" he he I just can't help my self".
Buster Bunny "Good work Babs"
Harry" Well tha tha that's all Muggles!"
Looney Warner mouse" Good Morning and Good after noon and good night and good luck!"
Have a real good week and weekend.
fade out to black.
input cartoon sound track Called Merry go round Broke down.
Hamton J Pig " tha tha tha that's all Folks!"
the end!
Author Feedback: You are too kind as always, thanks for reading.
 

love&memories
Signed | Chapter : 1 | Date : 11/06/09
Oh the end. How sad. But no, I do not agree with you. To me, it doesn't fall flat at all. I like how she sent that letter and it made him deal with it. And I love Harry leaving the wedding invitation. I do like how honest it was with Ron saying part of him hoped it would fall apart. All in all a wonderful series.
Author Feedback: It seems to be the general concensus that this installment did not fall short in the least and considering that I can see no way of changing it I will accept it as it is. Thank you for reading I am happy that you enjoyed the series.
 

NightlanzerX
Unsigned | Chapter : 1 | Date : 11/06/09
That was a great piece! I thought you portrayed Ron spot on. I get what you mean by this falling a bit flat. Perhaps one more piece told in a general point of view that has to do with the four of them together once more. I'm not sure, but I hope that you keep writing stories!
Author Feedback: Second person to suggest another installment of some sort... hmmm... its something to think about.
 

Anonymous
Unsigned | Chapter : 1 | Date : 11/06/09
It's missing a little something, but I couldn't tell you what. I'm not sure. Maybe it's because the description of him getting over it all went so quickly. Or the fact that Harry and Hermione have definitely found happiness, but Ginny and Ron still haven't quite moved on or something. I know you've said before they aren't pining, but they seem a little stuck in the past at the same time. I don't like thinking of Ron (a decent Ron, that is, and he's very decent here) still in mourning. I did like it, but it didn't draw me in the way a couple of the other ones did.

But don't let that discourage you. I love your stories. I'll read every last one of them.
Author Feedback: I think you are right in saying that it is hard to see someone hurting for so long without wanting them to have something good in their life. I think that is the case here you want something good for Ron and Ginny as well. And no I do not see it as pining but I think if you are truly in love with someone and something like that happened you would be a bit guarded in giving your heart to anyone else.

Thanks for all the encouraging words and for reading and reviewing.
 

Anonymous
Unsigned | Chapter : 1 | Date : 11/06/09
As usual, your stories are always interesting. Multiple viewpoints of the same plot. I\'ve seen two but not four. Will you do anyone else?

N.O.C.
Author Feedback: I had not considered doing anyone else but should the muse so lead...
 

Dome 36
Unsigned | Chapter : 1 | Date : 11/06/09
I have several things to say about this final installment of your series:

1 - You had the courage, that no one in Portkey had until now, to admit that "Hermione was the love of Ron's life". If we are honest, and I underscore if we are honest, Hermione WAS the love of Ron's life. Period. I know that in Portkey, attitudes towards Ron are divided in two options:
a) Hate - which is very popular;

b) Making him behave badly, in order to justify the rift between Hermione and him. And then, like some sort of magic, Ron starts to be an angel, so that Luna can be romantically involved with him. Usually this sounds so false, that automatically I feel sorry for Luna, because she is going to be involved with a nasty person/character. This attitude is dictated with the will to "compensate Ron". In this sense of the word, Luna is basically the "compensation girl", which makes her a really sad character. She basically exists to "compensate".

Your set of stories is very different. And for the better. Probably you wrote one of the best Portkey fics ever. Because it is realistic. Because it is honest.

2 - Ron's reaction was understandable - to drink and to try to forget his humiliation. And the destruction of his dreams of happiness.

3 - It seems that people don't see the kind of society that the wizarding world is: a very little community where almost everyone knows everyone. From that day forth, Ron is known as "the one that Hermione rejected". Taking into account the little dimension of the said community this is basically awful.

4 - And in here, once again, I still don't believe in the rebuilt of a friendship: if Hermione had the gutz to end things, let's say two weeks before the wedding... well, that would hurt, but it will be different. But to end things that way? It is too much. Like I said in my previous review, everything in your set of stories is dramatic and sensible. This is the only matter where I simply can't agree. Ron might forgive, yes. But to really want to rebuilt a friendship? No. That is asking too much. Because everytime Ron would seen his two friends, happy and in love, he would be reminded (painfully reminded) of the fact that he failed the chance to be happy with the love of his life.

You have talent! Accept my congratulations!

Dome 36
Author Feedback: I thank you for your very thoughtful review and I humbly accept your praise and congratulations. I did indeed want to be as realisic as possible and I think I did that reasonably well.

My only concern is that I think I have somehow (through the wrong choice of words I think) conveyed that Ron, Hermione and Harry are the trio of old. As you say the wizarding world is exceedingly small. Thus more often than not the three will find themselves in certain situations where it would be unbearable to be around each other if some sense of civility was maintained. So when I say (incorrectly) rebuilt their friendship I mean that they can be civilized in public and perhaps the occasional congratulations at the birth of a child etc., hence sending a picture to Molly every few years. I never intended it to sound as if they had dinners together or anything of that nature.

Thank you again for your thought provoking and insightful reviews.
 

jump   | next >>
 

Page generated in 0.01004 seconds. 184 users currently online.
Server running: Portkey Version 2, coded by James & Skinned by Imran(NAPPA).