chelley83Signed | Chapter : 1 | Date : 25/05/09
i liked how you wrote this, and i hope that the ending means they're more than just sex now  j/k i know that they are, it came across very well...thanks for writing this, it's good |
| |
shadyBLUESigned | Chapter : 1 | Date : 18/04/09
i enjoyed this story. am feeling rather sick and i needed some h/hr. this surely help. thanks! |
| |
I first read this a few days ago but upon the urge to read something, clicked it again because I remembered I had enjoyed it (always a good sign to an author if a fic has a lot of re-readability  .
You said this was supposed to be an exercise in prose over merely dialogue-driven. I think you did well with both, but each time I read this, I didn't realize where they were at during the current conversation. I keep thinking at the first that Hermione had left Harry's place and was sleeping in her own bed, with her home office/desk in her bedroom, then suddenly it jumps - Hermione's in the desk chair and they're at work. That always throws me. Perhaps just a single sentence added near the beginning might better clear that up for the reader? I think even if you just simply amended the first sentence to "heard the sound of HER OFFICE door slamming" would be sufficient.
Fantastic job, though! I love the small subtleties
H&H4EVA
Hermione Rae |
Author Feedback: good lord, i never thought my work would be worthy of re-reading... wow... what a shock to my system that statement was. thank you  .
lol, i can see what you mean about being more explicit and you're definitely on point in regards to that, i'll be sure to go back to it when i have a chance and clarify that little tidbit.
thank you very much,
cosmo
xx |
| |
Cofre_713Signed | Chapter : 1 | Date : 16/04/09
I believe it was a perfect combination of both dialogue-driven and detail oriented prose.
And kuddos for trying different things and improving your skills as a writer, even if it's "just fanfiction".
I, personally, find very tiresome the stories that tend to the use of only one style of prose.
I hardly read an entire chapter, and that's coming from a VERY curious person. |
Author Feedback: oh thank you so much  wow... this review has left me so terribly red that i can only imagine what someone would think if they were to come across me right now, lol. |
| |
|
Love it! Keep on writing, cause I do love your stuff. Have a great day! |
Author Feedback: thank you, and you too! |
| |
|
That was certainly interesting and well-written, but there are two things I would like to point out:
1. I found the language to be a little bit rough for the situation. Now, don't get me wrong, I'm not the sort of person who covers their ears and screams whenever they hear someone swear, nor am I completely innocent of the act, but I just found that Harry's choice of words was a little bit too strong for the situation at hand. I know he was upset by the note, but it just doesn't seem natural for him to get so worked up right away, especially with a woman who he loves.
2. It's written that Harry and Hermione were having an 'affair', but you said that they were both single. By 'affair', did you just mean a relationship, or was it an actual affair-with-a-capital-'A'?
Other than that, I really liked this piece! The 'misplaced kiss on New Year's' idea was a wonderful source of cute mental images, and I also liked Hermione's admission of the fact that she can't be 'that girl', even for Harry. It was wonderfully in-character for her.
Excellent; keep it up! |
Author Feedback: 1. yeah, i'll admit: i'm a potty mouth. personally i blame it upon my slavic heritage (english is my third language) and in my maternal language we tend to curse... a lot, as in every other word is a curse so that tends to translate into my work a bit (okay, far) more often than i'd like. thank you for that note, i truly am trying to control that and having it commented on by a reader like this is only additional drive to ameliorate this dilemma, i think.
2. no, by affair i simply mean that the relationship was behind everyone's back. no one really knew about it, it was just a casual thing which can't really be classified as a relationship so i used the term affair, but the connotation there wasn't intended to be derogatory.
3. i am so glad to hear that the imagery was there, it's something that i truly struggle with in a lot of my work as i tend to be a more mathematically inclined person who is very cut&dray/to the point so even creative writing is out of comfort zone, i'll admit. but it's so relaxing... lol.
thank you ever so much for the feedback. |
| |
AnonymousUnsigned | Chapter : 1 | Date : 14/04/09
You know, Cosmo, if you really suck at writing smut (and I seriously doubt you do, btw), then the only way to get any better at it is to practice, practice, practice.  |
Author Feedback: aw, thank you, that is incredibly kind of you to say, and i truly appreciate... hell, i may even give it a go now... maybe i should research it a bit first
|
| |
gingercatSigned | Chapter : 1 | Date : 14/04/09
Cute....the language was fine....good grief!! Good to see Harry not being shy about his feelings for Hermione....FINALLY!! |
Author Feedback: thank you, i was so scared that it was too much after another review, i know i have quite a potty mouth and that tends to come out in my stories as well... |
| |
AnonymousUnsigned | Chapter : 1 | Date : 14/04/09
I believe with your frequent use of the F word you should change the rating to R. Sooooo unnecessary. |
Author Feedback: ak, i know, i have a terrible potty mouth... quite a contrast to how verbose i can be at pother times, but alas what can you do? i'm terribly sorry if this detracted from the story, for you. |
| |
|
Job well done by Hermione to get a commitment out of Harry!! |
Author Feedback: lol, it wasn't intentional, but it worked out rather well for her, didn't it?  |
| |
|
That was really sweet, thanks for writing it. I would like to see it become more than just a one-shot, I think you could quite easily continue where you left off here. Sort of have them officially become a couple and letting everyone know.
I love it when people write 'possessive Harry' style stories and whilst this one-shot is lovely and could stand alone I think lots of people would be happy to see it turn into something bigger.
Thanks for putting it on here for us!
Jacquianne. |
Author Feedback: see the only way that continuing this wouldn't be horrifically boring would be if i added smut... and... well i'm crap at writing smut, i just come off as this creepy kinky, pervert; it's so sad.
thank you so much for the support, i truly appreciate it, it means the world to me, honestly.
cosmo
xx |
| |
|
i honestly liked it a lot, maybe you can go and write a little prequel to this give us the night it all started in more vivid detail. my only complaint was the legnth ending it right when you did is a good spot to end but did it neccesserily have to? |
Author Feedback: both continuing it and writing a prequel are just two ideas that i would love to take on, but the problem i suck at writing smut so it'd be more of a let down than anythign else... but thank you so much for the support nevertheless, i truly appreciate it. |
| |
icemiceUnsigned | Chapter : 1 | Date : 14/04/09
Love it! I like the shortness of it, the brevity yet lightness of the plot. I like the flirtatious interchange between the leads, and....I LOVE IT!!! Maybe, ..maybe...you could expand it and write another chapter? into it??...flighty wishes springing forth...... |
Author Feedback: sadly, that would require smut, and i'm total shit at writing that, it always comes off so terribly kinky that i just sound like the world's biggest pervert, lol. it would have been nice to continue it though--ah, if only... |
| |
indy_louUnsigned | Chapter : 1 | Date : 14/04/09
I loved this story.
Once again you have managed to capture the uniqueness of Harry and Hermione's characters and portray them beautifully. |
Author Feedback: wow, what kind words... not too sure if i deserve such praise, but thank you ever so much nevertheless... |
| |
AnonymousUnsigned | Chapter : 1 | Date : 14/04/09
I enjoyed it. I like my Harry just a little possessive. Not insane-hello-shades-of-Weasley-possessive, but just enough that he's not afraid to take what's his. Great job. |
Author Feedback: lol, i'm so happy to hear that, thank you! |
| |
|