JIMUnsigned | Chapter : 34 | Date : 11/03/10
Neville is an ass.
Nice to see an update.....it has been such a very long time. I'm glad things are getting back on track for you, and I hope they stay that way. Not a whole lot in this chapter to comment on as you are just finishing up the rest of the story. It has been an amazing ride, and I cannot wait for the final few chapters. This is easily the best H/HR fic to come out in a very long time. |
Author Feedback: I rather suspect Neville is a prankster.
You're right about the next few chapters being the tidying-up of the story... but I hope I may have a few twists left in store for you. Thank you, once again, for your encouragement... it's been a big help. |
| |
CokieismeSigned | Chapter : 34 | Date : 11/03/10
Sorry to hear it sucked. Winter was awful for me as well. Let's hope spring will be better. Loved the update. And nevilles little bomb, where oh where is this going. Ill be waiting!!! |
Author Feedback: Spring is still pretty busy... but not as busy as winter was! Glad you enjoyed the update... thank you.
As for where Neville's little bomb will lead us -- that will be next chapter, as Hermione's Rebirthday Party continues. |
| |
addisonjSigned | Chapter : 34 | Date : 11/03/10
OMG! Getting this chapter update in my email is like getting my own birthday present! Glad you've recovered and are writing again. Your own of my favorite authors and this is one of my favorite stories.
Have harry return to hogwarts for seventh year? Classmates with his godson? He would certainly be a cub to hermiones cougar then. Not recommended. Harry could stay at godrics hollow and apparate to and from hermiones everyday.
Welcome back. Glad you're back and recovered. |
Author Feedback: Harry returning to Hogwarts would have one side-effect: it would permanently fix in the public's mind how much "younger" he is than Hermione. Which may be a strong inducement to *not* return to Hogwarts... we'll wait and see.
Thank you for the kind words! I'm glad to be back. I hope to keep you glad as well. |
| |
|
Neville! Damn your indisputable logic! And they were so close, too. Oh well, that's a relatively minor obstacle. More interesting by far is the continuing Rose plot, and I can't imagine you're going to let the Malfoys go unmentioned in the remaining story.
Looking forward to more. |
Author Feedback: Neville may want to rethink his indisputable logic: having two sons of Marauders in Gryffindor may be more trouble than it's worth.
The Rose subplot will continue, and we'll see the Malfoys again soon enough. Plus a couple of others...
Thanks for the review. It's good to be back. |
| |
|
I am really enjoying the story so far and look forward to reading the rest. |
Author Feedback: You're in luck, then: the next chapter has just been posted! Thanks for reading... and let me know what you think. |
| |
|
Awesome story! It reads like some of the finest mystery novels, giving just enough clues to keep the reader guessing until you drop the hammer on the bad guy. For some reason though, I keep waiting for the evidence to come out that Kingsley was being slowly murdered, via the potions he was forced to take by his healer. And the healer to also have memory blocks...
I did guess how Ron and Hermione's marriage would end, so to speak. I thought that Ron would die...permanently... oh well... |
Author Feedback: Thank you! Yes, there are elements of mystery novels, bits of spy thrillers, and of course the bits of CSI: Magical World.
Many readers expected me to kill Ron, so you weren't alone. But this works, too.
Next chapter is with my beta, so with luck will be posted very soon. Stay tuned... and thank you again. |
| |
N.O.C.Signed | Chapter : 33 | Date : 04/03/10
|
Author Feedback: You're welcome a bunch! Feel free to read the whole story again (it has been a few months, hasn't it)... I tend to do that too, just to make sure I've not contradicted myself. (Unlike certain highly-paid authoresses.)
Soon as my beta has signed off on the chapter, it will be posted! Yay! |
| |
RT your response to my review (lol) :
awww. I'm so glad you remember me! I've been away from portkey for so long I feared I was forgotten.
yay! I can't wait.  ) |
Author Feedback: Of course I remember you, and fondly, too.  Welcome home.
Next chapter is coming very soon, so keep close watch. Have a good week! |
| |
oh. this is good. i missed this. (and it's my fault).
but i'm all caught up now. can't wait for more. |
Author Feedback: Your timing is impeccable: the next chapter has been sent to my beta, and assuming all goes well, will be posted here within a few days. Watch this space!
And have I mentioned how grateful I am to my reviewers? Thank you. |
| |
AnonymousUnsigned | Chapter : 33 | Date : 25/02/10
It's not bad. Certainly well written, the romance is decently developed and the concepts are sound. There are parts though where I need to back up andf say "Wait, what?" |
Author Feedback: Thank you for your compliments on the good points of the story. I'd be interested to know, though, which parts made you back up and say, "whaaaa?" (Some of the items that garnered the most commentary -- house elf prostitution, for instance -- I saw as logical developments, given what we have in canon and combining it with the history of slavery.)
But ultimately, the purpose of the story is entertainment, and if I kept you reading, and entertained, then all is well. Thank you for reviewing -- I appreciate it. |
| |
N.O.C.Signed | Chapter : 33 | Date : 17/02/10
 Yeaaaaahhhh, he lives,,, through devastating personal ordeals from beyond the veil and has responded to all. Thats the first sign of getting better when you think you've gone insane with stress.  You start to right about it, maybe you can use some of the personal problems in the storyline...its something that isn't hard to right because you already know how its going to turn out.
Well I'm certainly happy to have you back, so now how about that next chapter? |
Author Feedback: Yeah, he lives... and still writes, honestly he does. And just so's you know, the next chapter *has been sent* to my beta for review. With any luck, and assuming she doesn't find a terrible blunder that forces me to rip it apart and start over, the chapter will be here in a few days.
Service with a smile. |
| |
morrUnsigned | Chapter : 33 | Date : 17/02/10
Ooops. I'm really sorry, I didn't want to offend anyone with the "normal people" remark. I should have phrased it differently: people who confess their love to someone *for the first time* do not usually talk like that. "And for the record" sounds exactly like something a married couple might say - there is tenderness in there, and playfulness and some good-natured teasing (and first-time confessions are usually serious business  Thank you so much for responding - I'll be on the look-out for future updates. - morr |
Author Feedback: Don't worry about it, I wasn't offended.  And as I said, I'm not normal (just ask my wife) -- among other things, I write fanfiction.
The tenderness and playfulness was what I was trying for, in that scene. Granted, people who've just fallen in love for the first time don't always have the emotional maturity to joke about it... but Harry's 33 and Hermione's 34, so I assumed the maturity was there. Just as well: teen angst? Not for *this* couple.
In related news, the next chapter's with my beta, so with luck should be posted soon. Please let me know what you think of it... and thank you again. |
| |
JIMUnsigned | Chapter : 33 | Date : 13/02/10
Did you abandon this? It's been quite a few months. I was just wondering....I hope you get back to this story soon. We were so close to the end at least I think we were...Ugh, updates, I need them. |
Author Feedback: Nope, not abandoned. Just incredibly sidetracked by Real Life. I'll see what I can do to ease your pain, as soon as I can. |
| |
morrUnsigned | Chapter : 33 | Date : 11/02/10
Wow. I might be an English major (not my first language, though), but this story left me dumbstruck and struggling for words other than "wow". I haven't read portkey fanfiction for a long while, and just recently someone recommended this story to me. Believe it or not, but on that very day I stayed up reading until five in the morning, until I almost fell asleep and broke the keyboard with my face, because I could not force myself to stop in the middle. I cannot remember the last time I was so excited about a story. After reading the final HP book, with the godawful epilogue, I totally gave up on the series for a while - on that day I felt like a little kid who found out that her broken toy had been fixed.
I really liked how you took care to describe Hermione's workplace, her colleagues, her flat (loved the name, BTW) and her daily routine, giving the reader a realistic glimpse of what her life might be like post-Hogwarts. I liked how you described her job and her efforts to introduce a new piece of legislation - this was something she would definitely do. And I absolutely LOVED how you handled the long, drawn-out reconciliation between Harry and Hermione. It was very guarded (but still emotional) at first, and then we could slowly see the barriers drop, one by one. You have a great hand for dialogue - their first meeting was heart-wrenching and then, later, when Harry said: "Eggs?" I felt my heart skip a beat, because that short phrase conveyed so much. The ending for that chapter is probably my favourite bit (oh, and just because I'm a sucker for references, I loved how Hermione was like Scotland  )
My only reservation about the H/Hr plotline was with their first long-awaited intimate moment. With the whole build-up, which was wonderfully awkward, subtle and superbly done, the bed scene seemed sort of... heavy-handed. Just a feeling, but... seriously, it took Hermione this one look from Harry to a) establish the true nature of his feelings towards her b) come to terms with them, and become comfortable enough to perform the equivalent of using a sex toy in the bedroom - just like that? And I'm really sorry to say this, but: "And for the record, Mr. Potter, I love you too." sounds like something straight from a corny fanfic written by a 14-year old girl. People don't talk like that. I loved the rest of you story, but this scene just doesn't ring true.
Romantic bits aside, I really enjoyed the political/criminal plotline - it was clever, chilling, and gave the story a wider social background, plus, your characters are generally well-written, even the ministry employees are fun to follow around. Canon characters are great, except that Ron and Ginny usually get the hard end of the stick (although Ron is not that bad: he is still Harry's friend, he's fiercely protective of Ginny, and he has his shining moments of glory - loved the rubber haddock scene  )
Thank you for putting so much time and effort into this story. I really hope that you'll be able to finish it someday, because such a good story deserves to be completed. Take care! - morr |
Author Feedback: Wow right back at you. This review was pretty "wow" itself -- and from a first-time reader! Thank you, thank you.
I never really got the feeling that Ms Rowling actually fleshed out the world she created: there was a Minister, therefore a Ministry, and a few other details, but by and large, the workings of the wizarding world remain a mystery to us. Well, I daresay our own governments' workings wouldn't be obvious to a visitor from Mars, but I was hoping for a little more thought. I've tried to provide that here... and yes, Hermione in canon seems a prime candidate for the sort of social engineering I've shown in this story.
Mmm, the bedroom scene... never one of my strong suits, bedroom scenes. Although the line "for the record, etc", is pretty much the sort of thing my wife and I say to each other, so I thought it would at least be plausible. (Ah, but then, we already know I'm not normal: I write fanfiction.  ) Anyway, that bit aside, I'm glad you've enjoyed the rest of the story.
As for Ron and Ginny, remember, the story extrapolates what they *would* have been like, if Harry had disappeared. Ginny, I'm quite convinced, would move on past Harry in pretty short order; while Ron's negative points would become stronger over time, not lessen. But as you say, Ron has his shining moments, too. I can't make myself write him as a *complete* berk.
I fully intend to finish the story, but I felt I had to respond to reviewers first. I feel bad I couldn't respond sooner, but my life... well, the less said, the better. I hope to complete this chapter in short order, so keep an eye for it. And thank you again. |
| |
|
Just marking my place in this fabulous story... in case you decide to add som more to it that is... |
Author Feedback: I will, my lady, as soon as I can! Forgive me for taking so long to respond to your note -- and thank you for sending it. |
| |
|