AnonymousUnsigned | Chapter : 1 | Date : 17/04/09
I love this story already and I must say, it\'s one of a kind! I\'ve never read a story with a plot like this and, surprisingly, it\'s just the story I wanted! |
Author Feedback: wow, thank you so much for that wonderful review! |
| |
AnonymousUnsigned | Chapter : 1 | Date : 16/03/09
Eheh, eheh... So sorry about that last review about 'Lily and James always breaking up in the end'. I thought this was another one-shot. Eheh. Eheh. Oops. |
Author Feedback: thank you for that apology, i greatly appreciate it as i must admit that i was a bit hurt by the statement. i wasn't aware that my works were so morbid, honestly. |
| |
AnonymousUnsigned | Chapter : 1 | Date : 16/03/09
Must you always to stories that end up with Lily and James breaking up?  It's getting my rather depressed. |
Author Feedback: acutally, this starts off with them breakign up, it does not END with that,thank you very much. and as for this choice, it's not as if all of my stories involve that theme, if interested here is a list of stories that dont [off the top of my head]:
-i know that you sleep with my boyfriend
-losing it all
-the pick up line
-like a romantic comedy
-darcy
-good bye my almost lover
-reporter girl |
| |
piper_09Signed | Chapter : 12 | Date : 11/06/08
awwwwwwwww!!!!!!  that was the most prettiest ending ever!!!!!!!!  Gosh this is another good story!!!! it was really good especially this part"Lily,” he sighed, leaning his forehead against her own as he closed his eyes. “You need me, Lils; you need me as much as I need you. We can work,” he promised, “We can do it. Everything's a learning experience and this can only make us stronger. That's what they always say in those ruddy chick flicks you con me into watching. Why can't you follow their example when you love them so much?”
“Because—because I've been there—felt the pain.”
He winced slightly before opening his eyes. “I love you, Lils,” he whispered before crushing her lips with his own in a searing, toe curling, shag-me-for-days-on-end worthy kiss.
She couldn't help, but respond, it had become a reflex after all those years with him—all that time spent loving him. She let the tears free as she poured her heart into the kiss, trying to use it as a release for all the pain she'd felt over the years—all the hell that they'd wrought upon one another, each screwing up in their own way.
She used it as a means of discharging all that pent up aggression towards the fates for having mucked everything up for them.
He pulled away, slowly wiping away the tears. “Don't cry,” he whispered, “please don't cry.” " It felt like i was watching a frikin soap opera, it was tense! I absolutely
 ed it. Keep writing!!!!!!!!!!! |
| |
EmmZbrUnsigned | Chapter : 12 | Date : 10/06/08
Oh dear.
I used up SEVEN whole tissues for that story!
That's a LOT for me!
Beautiful, totally captivating, I love it.
Constructive criticism? I really don't know how you could make it better.
It's so chock-full of emotions, but it's amazingly realistic.
Brilliant work.
I've seen you before on fanfiction.net, and I think I am correct in saying you have some of the same stories posted on there.
I don't have an account on this site, but on FF.net I will definitely be adding you to my favorites list.
(Name is EmmZbr, that's why I signed like that.)
Again, wonderful job, keep it up!  |
| |
GemmaH121Signed | Chapter : 12 | Date : 08/06/08
Oh wow that was great. I am glad they are back together. I thought it was sad that they'd given up but maybe they needed that. Anyway I thought you wrote it well and I am glad Lily realised that some of it is her fault as well and admitted to that. |
| |
Harry85Signed | Chapter : 12 | Date : 08/06/08
Oook, so in the end they are together again, how nice!  The only problem I see with that is that Lily's behaviour doesn't make sense to me. I mean, for eleven chaps she's thrown all his mistakes in his face, then he finally decides to leave, and she's dumbfounded (bloody hell, woman, what else did you expect?) and hurt that he did...then here again she doesn't seem to want to go back with him because she's afraid of the hurt...I really don't understand her.
Another thing that I didn't like is that we don't know much of how Lily felt during that time apart. I mean, James admitted realizing life without her was hell, but what about Lily? I think she should have been the one to miss him more, just so that she may truly understand the mistake she made asking for a divorce. She deservd that for hurting him.
In the end, I would have preferred they hadn't split up at all, but if they truly needed to split, this is not exactly the way I'd have written their reunion, I'd have had Lily be the one wanting to get back together, and James resisting her just so that she would have had to fight to go back with him, like she deserved.
Sorry for the long review |
Author Feedback: thing is, 3 years have passed, that's a lot of time to change. that's a lot of time to grow up and finally realized that you've made mistakes as well. i think that had lily not realized it there would have been a greater problenm with her given that it'd mean she cant mature at all.
as for how lily felt, she DID love him, always had. maybe she was hurt by him but it was never a question of whether she loved him or not, i'm sorry that i didnt make hat fact more evident tho...
as for lily wanting to get back together... i think that it's not so much a question of whether she wants to, but if there's hope for them, if they can actually make it work--that's her worry. she's scared of what they do to eachother and hwo they always seem to hurt one another
but i get why you might not like lily in this fic sowould want her to have her heart broken as she did to him... ppl either hate lily or hate james (majority being the latter) in this fic
thank you for reviewing! |
| |
AnonymousUnsigned | Chapter : 11 | Date : 07/06/08
that hurts... that really hurts... wow amazin writin.. keep goin gal!! |
| |
xdv__Signed | Chapter : 11 | Date : 07/06/08
I know i said i wouldn't mind if they didn't get back together, but maybe now i'm thinking a little differently. i guess, as long as they both end up happy in the story. sigh, i eargerly await the last chap. |
Author Feedback: ah see that's how you know you're a lily and ajmes fan to the core  |
| |
GemmaH121Signed | Chapter : 11 | Date : 06/06/08
OMG it's really over for them. How sad. I think you did a good job of making it realistic though and they remembered good stuff as well as the bad. It sounds like both of them still care about eachother but just not enough to stay together. You did a great job with this story I enjoyed reading it and am looking forward to reading the epilouge. |
Author Feedback: yeah, is pretty sad, you dont actually even expecit it t happen-i know i didnt,m and i wrote the piece lol
as for your comments all i'll say is that those are some very astute observations |
| |
GemmaH121Signed | Chapter : 10 | Date : 06/06/08
Great chapter. I liked the scene with Lily at her parents funeral. |
Author Feedback: thank you so much, i was afraid someone would tell me i suck at funerals and my chap was a blasphemus piece of crap  >.< lol |
| |
AnonymousUnsigned | Chapter : 11 | Date : 05/06/08
R U really gonna end it between Lily and James? Pleaze don\'t! |
Author Feedback: u'll just have to read and wee, i'm afraid  |
| |
Harry85Signed | Chapter : 11 | Date : 05/06/08
Ah, so that she's finally broken him with all her complaining and her unwillingness to fight, now she tells him there were good times? It's a bit late, isn't it, Lily? |
Author Feedback: lol, we're all blind to our faults sometimes, and, yeah, ti can be a bit annoying-- but it's more so the fact that it's a reality shock for her, the fact that it really is over. much liek for the reader, it didnt feel totaly over for her until he finally said those words
altho, have to admit, it is a bit late  |
| |
piper_09Signed | Chapter : 11 | Date : 05/06/08
bun,bum,bummmmmm, oh that was so gooood!!!!!!1  ,i am really liking this story. Keep writing!!!! |
Author Feedback: aw thnak you, i'm so glad to hear you werent detered by that sad chap! |
| |
Harry85Signed | Chapter : 10 | Date : 03/06/08
Lily is really becoming annoying, you know? With her continuous repeating of "I can't"... |
Author Feedback: lol, just remember that this entire convo takes place over a course of 2 hrs  |
| |
|