LOGIN PANEL :

Displaying Reviews for
And so I Smile

Total Reviews: 60

View chapters for a specific chapter:

<< prev
jump   | next >>
FlameButt
Signed | Chapter : 4 | Date : 09/06/08
I enjoyed the tension that you infused in the story with them both thinking they knew what the other wanted them to do and kept us believing that we might end up with a tragic finale (both married to the wrong people) but you 'pulled it out the fire' with aplomb. The only thing I would ask is NO EPILOGUE - what is it with these people Just because JKR did one in book 7 doesn't mean everyone other author has to do the same.
 

Harry85
Signed | Chapter : 4 | Date : 09/06/08
Just so you know, I have no problem with mature Ginny and Ron, I use them often in my fics (although, equally often they are royal prats ). It's just the timing of Ron telling her what he knows that I find really difficult to believe. He might have asked her for a confrontation about her true feelings, hoping to be mistaken, just like he did, only NOT when he did it.
As for the marriage thing, that's what bothers me the most. I could have handled Ron's plan to make her see the truth about her and Harry proposing to he rin front of Harry, if they were at some party, or something like that, but not when Harry's already married to Ginny. I mean, honeslty, they might not have consummated the marriage yet like you said, but they ARE married. This will make both Harry and Ginny look like fools, especially Harry. I know drama adds to a story, but when it has a logical solution. I'm sorry to say this, but the way you pulled the happy ending doesn't make sense (no offense meant, only the way I see it)

I'm not sure even an epilogue can fix that, because what's done is done, but I'm willing to read if you do write it.
 

Queen Dragon
Unsigned | Chapter : 3 | Date : 09/06/08
I'm CONFUSED Isn't Harry still married to Ginny, so how is he and Hermione gonna get together!!! Also, I think there should be an epilogue, so we can understand how they were able to finally get together. Not with Harry still married, but with Hermione and Harry get married. Cuz I'm confused on the whole Harry and Ginny still married and at their reception!! I Still LOVE THE STORY!!
 

Sami
Unsigned | Chapter : 2 | Date : 09/06/08
OMG, so sad! Story of my life. Please make it happy fluff!
 

HcintaHr
Unsigned | Chapter : 1 | Date : 09/06/08
This is really a sad piece. Wonderful description of how hermione might feel. I've always wondered about that moment when she 'beamed'. If only it were any other way
 

Ash
Unsigned | Chapter : 3 | Date : 09/06/08
oh that was such a fantastic ending! Ron was just so well, smart to come up with a plan like that. It was also very noble and generous to sacrafice his own happiness for his friends. In a sense that could be called love\'s greatest sacrafice. Well done!
 

Harry85
Signed | Chapter : 3 | Date : 09/06/08
ok, I'll be honest. I don't really like this chapter much. There are some things that make it hard for me to like. First, it doesn't really make sense that Ron knows they love each other, and had to pull that stunt to prove it. He should have talked with Hermione before the wedding, and have her see the truth.

Second, I don't like that it's Ron to point them in the right direction.

Third, Harry's still married to Ginny. I know they can get a divorce, but seriously, it IS a bit pathetic to get a divorce mere hours after you got married, isn't it?

So basically this whole revealing of feelings should have been done before the wedding, I think. Oh, I know, it would have taken much of the drama out of the first two chapters, but it would have made more sense, in my opinion. I mean, this way it seems you just wanted to force the first two chapters to be really dramatic without having a "logical" resolution for it.

I hope you're not offended by my review, it's not my aim, I don't want to flame. I just like to be honest with my thoughts, it would be much easier to say "Hey, it's brilliant" but I'd still think what I've written, so...
 

Ash
Unsigned | Chapter : 2 | Date : 09/06/08
Another more heartbreaking chpater! Superb writing in this chapter, I love the way harry describes "His Mione". The wedding is so depressing, oh dear it just makes me want to chuck an anvil at both of them! It might knock some sense into them lol Great chapter, onto the last one...
 

Ash
Unsigned | Chapter : 1 | Date : 09/06/08
Oh that is so heartbreaking! Wathching the man you love getting married to another women! Poor Hermione! I thought this chapter was excellent, it conveyed just enough emotion in the amount of words it was given now onto the next heartbreaking chapter!
 

papermask
Signed | Chapter : 3 | Date : 09/06/08
I was wondering how Ron and Ginny were going to take this, but you wrapped everything up very nicely in the end. I like the last little twist. Very nice work.
 

Pour toujours
Signed | Chapter : 3 | Date : 09/06/08
Oh good god.
Sounds so much like my family..

Wonderful story..
It was written alright..
Only a few tweaks here and there could have made it better..
I enjoyed it!
-Pour Toujours
 

floomehere!
Signed | Chapter : 3 | Date : 09/06/08
Woah, I thought this story was done! A welcome new chapter, though. Everything worked out in the end, but the insanely mature Ron and Ginny kind of threw me off for a bit. I guess PK writers usually like to show them as selfish and jealous . I thought you were going to write about everyone else's reactions (parents, friends, relatives, etc) - epilogue?
 

Amanda
Unsigned | Chapter : 2 | Date : 06/06/08
awwwww Make it a love sick puppy story! fluff! This is a fantastic story and i look forward to the rest!
 

xXflossieXx
Unsigned | Chapter : 2 | Date : 16/04/08
I don't think I have ever read a story that made me dry so much!!
Espcially the bits when it says "I'm hollow inside and if I don't get out of here soon I just may die on the spot but I still smile. She's my Mione and so I give her what she wants, even if it hurts."
Please don't let this be the last chapter!!!
 

Anonymous
Unsigned | Chapter : 1 | Date : 06/04/08
it made me tear up its so cute i loved it!
 

<< prev
jump   | next >>
 

Page generated in 0.01099 seconds. 215 users currently online.
Server running: Portkey Version 2, coded by James & Skinned by Imran(NAPPA).