I like it. Real life, or at least stories that seem to be are really one of my favorit things to read. It's the stuff that seems near impossible (even with magic) I don't like. Great job. I hope to read more in the future. And just so you know, at least one person on protkey likes post DHE fics.

---Tiger111991

Oh, I loved this one Gisele It was so cute! I hadn't read a one shot in a while, and this one left me wanting more! Keep up the great work =)

Good story. Please update soon. I'm one of those few people who likes post epilogue stories and loathes the stories where people ignore the epilogues. I want semi-canon fic, not completely ignore the epilogue fic. Please continue this.

Not bad. I don't think you suck as a writer, otherwise I'd have to think of myself as the worst writer on Earth's face I guess.

I haven't even read this fic yet and I want to write this review (after reading your A/N) - I think your work is great and if PortKey is being too partisan then I would, for one, follow you to which ever other fanfic site you move to!

I like the end a lot you know?

It´s a very sweet story,

Hey....it's a good start...but you ended it badly. There was more to be said, I think, and you let it trickle off. This one needs....more. More of the dialog; more of what Harry felt as he looked at her - just..something. I know you can do it!! Don't give up hope simply because some of the reviewers here are total twits. Trust me...it's a hard slog, but your work is worth it and I, for one, appreciate you.

Regards,

the_scribbler

sweety

Thank you for the reply and I am sorry for what happened, I know mathias did do it to make you feel sad, he just did not like the "idea"???. I read the reviews in Belong to Nowhere that you just updated and I'm happy to see so many good reviews and happy to know where you post your fic besides LJ, that site make me headaches becuase my time is soooo little. Be well and I hope to see you in a better mood. *Hugs*
Ana

I have no objection whatever to post 'epilogue' fics (note the apostrophes), because the original in book 7 was so obviously added as an afterthought.

Arguably though, had the 'epilogue' never been written as it was, yet another valuable source of Potter fics would have been denied us:-)

Back to your story I think it is certainly a more palatable and plausible scenario and well worth the effort you have obviously expended to create it.

As to whether the original 'epilogue' was the direct result of the administration of amorentia by any of the Weasley crowd remains speculative, but I'm pleased you sorted it out:-)

When an author has spent many hours and possibly months of their own time, working on an idea for a story, to have it ridiculed by some individual ot individuals whose own creative talent is limited to denigration of others' work is neither review nor criticism and certainly non-productive. If someone doesn't like a particular idea as outlined by the author, then they shouldn't try to belittle or browbeat the author into their own possibly small universe and find something else to read.

Anyway I've had my rant and please continue to write, I for one will look forward to your future efforts.

Saphos! Vivas et floreas diu. FS

Hi!!

Well, what can I say? It has been a year since I found your fics and I love them all, your writting is pretty nice and you could do it very well in differents Genres but you are awesome with the angst and drama which I love. Even if you stop to post at PK I hopo to read about you in you LJ and communities.

Thanks for the fic!.

Dave.

Hi Sweety

I have been reading your fics here as well as your LJ, I love them all and I am glad to see you back again here. I've been re-reading Love, Lies and a Secret and try to follow the updates in your LJ I love that fic. Please don't leave, don't pay attention to people that flames authors, they only do that because they are jealous!! . I have said this before, you wonderful writers share your work for FREE, you don't earn anything for it, the only payment you have is our reviews (constructive and nice preferably), that's why I said they do that out of jealousy!!.i only wish to have a little of your talent. Well I ranted enough, nice ficlet and hope to read more from you. Keep the excellent work

Ana