LOGIN PANEL :

Displaying Reviews for
Harry Potter and the Holy Spear

Total Reviews: 45

View chapters for a specific chapter:

<< prev
jump   | next >>
bookworm1291
Signed | Chapter : 4 | Date : 12/05/08
Great story! I love Indiana Jones, and Harry as Indie is great!! Can't wait to read more!!
Author Feedback: Thanks bookworm! I'm working on another chapter right now, so it shouldn't be too long until an update.
 

Mionefan
Signed | Chapter : 1 | Date : 22/03/08
How unique!! I think this one is pretty good, if not even funny. For Hermione not to realise she's magical is a bit of a stretch. I know Harry was unaware until Hagrid told him, but Hermione is much smarter than that. Good start though.
Author Feedback: Undoubtably she is, but it has always been my experience that people turn the other cheek to strange occurrences; pass them off as more mundane than they are. It's just human nature.
 

Mia Kyra Callwel
Signed | Chapter : 4 | Date : 20/03/08
Please please please update soon. I love it. It's very interesting.Is the answer to the first riddle death?
Author Feedback: I'll try, I promise you that. As soon as I can churn out a few other chapters for some other stories, this one will be updated.

Interestingly no, it isn't. That is a good one though. But for the actual answer...I think I'm going to leave you hanging there I'm afraid. *shrug* Sorry
 

louisemills1
Signed | Chapter : 4 | Date : 07/03/08
I like your story idea, very unique. I hope you update soon, as I would really like to see what you write next!
 

PJ
Signed | Chapter : 4 | Date : 06/03/08
Argh, so short!

OK, now you know I'll have to read the next chapter.



And I have to make this a short review because my little one is well enough to go to school tomorrow and she is attempting to escape her bedtime yet again.... get back in that bed you little monkey... yeah I saw that! my own Indy type of adventure to capture the evasive monkey and get her back in bed.

this story is getting more interesting with each update.



PJ *grabbing my monkey rangling gear now*
 

Angel 737
Signed | Chapter : 4 | Date : 06/03/08
This was really good! I'm really glad that you took the time to actually look stuff up for your chapters! I know that some people dont and used to be one of them but I am getting out of that habit... slowly... But having people like you do that makes me want to do it even more. There is nothing better than reading a story that has facts in them!

I cant wait to read more!
Author Feedback: Thanks Angel! Personally I have to say that it is a prerogative of all authors to ensure that their story is as good as it can be. It's good that you're working to improve, don't give up!
 

Crazy Mishka
Signed | Chapter : 4 | Date : 06/03/08
I have to ask, why in all hells is Hermione so unhelpful? I know right now she's the newbie (to the trio and to magic) but there has to be something that she can do to show them how worthwhile she is. Remus seemed to have confidence in her, so I was wondering what she could do.
Author Feedback: Hermione was primarily brought on board because she has around seventeen years of experience in tracking down mythological artefacts. Beyond that, she's the real brains of the outfit.

I'm sorry if she seems a bit useless, but I've tried to give each of them different areas of expertise.

Harry- Leadership, improvisation, moderate-high intelligence

Ron- Languages

Hermione- experience, high intelligence
 

Leolupin
Signed | Chapter : 4 | Date : 05/03/08
Fifty foot snakes would mess anyone up, even more so then falling into a bucket full of them. But nnakes are creepy in the first place.
Author Feedback: One would think, especially when the fifty-foot snake is bent on killing you.
 

Anonymous
Unsigned | Chapter : 3 | Date : 05/03/08
How did Harry and Ron know that Hermione was a witch???
Author Feedback: It's like...how people of Korean descent can always pick other Koerans out of a crowd of Asians. He just knows what to look for.
 

cibbler
Unsigned | Chapter : 4 | Date : 05/03/08
Big cliff alright. I was sitting at the edge of my chair at the end of this chapter. Excellent storytelling, looking forward to the next chapter.
 

Hana-xoxo
Signed | Chapter : 4 | Date : 05/03/08
WOW! WOW! WOW! WOW! WOW! WOW! WOW! WOW! WOW! A cliffie! oooh! I wonder what they are going to with them! You kept the mystery really good and I loved how Harry reacted!!! Brave and witty instead of wimpy! And I loved Ron here too!!! The riddle was so good!
I love this story! It is really good! Your charecterizations are just plain sensational! The emotions portrayed were done fantastically and I especially liked the part where they talked about Ginny! It had so much emotion from Harry who is just shown amazingly here; his appearance, his demeanour, the mysterious aura and I love it how you showed his vulnerabilities it was amazingly done! I loved it and it made him seem very human and I absolutely adored that!!! OMG!!!!!! They got captured dan dan da dan da da hence the REAL action! You writing is very good and I cannot wait until the next chappie!

xoxo
Hana
Author Feedback: Holy mother of ----!

Thanks, really! You have no idea how rewarding it is to get such positive feedback!
 

Oh_dang87
Unsigned | Chapter : 3 | Date : 18/02/08
I like this a lot so far! I hope you update very soon
 

PJ
Signed | Chapter : 3 | Date : 17/02/08
Remus ain't evil...he's just totally wicked! I so love him.

Hey look WCMD, I found the story after all. I'm glad I have, it is a good one. I like the Indiana Jones/Mummy/Lara Croft theme you have on this challenge. It is coming out very nicely indeed.



Looking forward to more.

PJ
 

Leolupin
Signed | Chapter : 3 | Date : 16/02/08
Hey Remus wasn't a Marauder for noting eh? Gerat stuff can't wait for more.

Is it done yet? Sorry I'm just excited becouse the trailer for Indy 4 was just relisesed, May 22 second will be a grand day for Leolupin!
Author Feedback: Yea, no kidding.

No, got a few chapters left I'm afraid.

Just saw the trailer myself. It looked good, but I miss the Indy of the 70's. The old TV serial style will always be Indy, and no fancy special effects will ever change that.
 

sparky40sw
Signed | Chapter : 3 | Date : 14/02/08
this is a really interesting start, and unfortunately, although I have seen several Harry/(insert famous treasure hunter here)crossovers begun - I have not yet seen one finished - I hope fervently that is the exception.
I am looking forward to seeing what methods you use to teach magic to Hermione.
thanks for sharing
Author Feedback: Well, while I realize there is no way for me to convince you, I assure you that I have no intention of abandoning this story. Plans change, but this isn't going to be very long either way.

And I'm not sure if I'm even going to show them teaching Hermione magic. I might just have them get the spear, kill Tom, and fast-forward a few years like the epilogue of doom(tm)
 

<< prev
jump   | next >>
 

Page generated in 0.00997 seconds. 152 users currently online.
Server running: Portkey Version 2, coded by James & Skinned by Imran(NAPPA).