usha88Signed | Chapter : 4 | Date : 11/05/08
Well, the ending was good. It did wrap it up nicely. I do think it progressed just a little too fast, but I liked it. Very interesting to read that Hermione mounted Harry in class..poor children. |
Author Feedback: Thanks usha, I appreciate it.
It did go really fast, but again: V2.0 should be coming out eventually. Don't worry about it.
*shrug* Those horny preggies. You never know what they're gonna do next |
| |
usha88Signed | Chapter : 3 | Date : 11/05/08
This was very short. I did like it. I wish that Hermione could've stayed angrier, but it does make sense. I wouldn't think that they would've had sex so soon. |
Author Feedback: It was. I'm glad.
Yes, you aren't the only one. Even I'm a little shocked by this, and I wrote it!
If you're interested: On the advice of the esteemed cosmopolitan411 *pause for applause*, I will at some point be doing a different version of this; a more drawn out version. I'm afraid I can't give an exact timeframe for it, but I'm suffering from major writer's block and I have God-only-knows how many other stories in-progress (both posted and not). Don't hold your breath, basically. |
| |
usha88Signed | Chapter : 2 | Date : 11/05/08
Well this is really interesting. I would like to know why Harry left and how Hermione coulld kiss him so easily. I hope there is more to come! |
Author Feedback: The first is explained in the next chapter, so I won't spoil it for you (of course you'll have probably read it by the time I reply to this, so it doesn't matter).
As to the second, confusion and residual feelings that she can't suppress no matter how hard she tries. I said this in a reply to an earlier review, but I had originally intended the conversation to be a 'you're an asshole but you made me realise some great cynical truth so I forgive you and let's just try to be friends' kind of a deal, but whatever higher power guides my writing decided to make them have hot make-up sex ten years overdue.
I'm glad that you're not terribly disgusted with the speed, yet. Hope you enjoy the rest! |
| |
usha88Signed | Chapter : 1 | Date : 11/05/08
This seems very interesting. Would like to know why Harry got a divorce and such. Lovely start to this story. |
Author Feedback: He didn't; Sarah did.
And she did because she knows perfectly well that Harry doesn't really love her like he does Hermione, however much he has tried to convince himself otherwise.
Thank you, I'm glad you enjoy it thus far. I hope the rest isn't too much of a disappointment; I move very quickly in this. |
| |
PMidNiteSigned | Chapter : 4 | Date : 18/03/08
"She had finally overcome her sporadic cravings, but then her libido shot through the roof. The memory of her walking into his class, pushing him over onto the desk, and mounting him, would haunt him to his dying day. Fortunately it had been a class of seventh-years, who at least knew what they were seeing. They still humbly requested to be obliviated, but it could have been much worse." OK thats one of the funniest things I've read in a while, Good job.
PapaMidNite
|
| |
esteemed cosmopolitan411?-- i like it  lol
so anyway, very interesting route... not what i expected (although, admittadley, i'm not all that perceptive given that you made it quite clear with your last chaps that it'd be at elast soemwhere along these lines)
this was just one fo those thigns where you dotn know where you stand with it
on one hand it's an amazing premise and this was deffinitley, in many ways, an original and unorthodox approach to it. but, then again, it was also a bit unerving seeing how many thigns harry was able to get away with it
ah.... i give it 8 to a 9 out of ten (fluxuates from tiem to time given my mood)
casnt wait for the other version though, i simply adore your prose and this fic has proven to me that regardless of the choice of development, in regards to the plot, i cant help but adore your writing lol
p.s. she actually said wealey 3 times... and granger twice
p.p.s. just b/c harry doesnt want to hear the story as to howthat whole ting came about doesnt mean that we, the readers,m dont lol
|
Author Feedback: Hey, you deserve it.
I've said it before and I'll say it again, it is a little surprising to me too.
I'll try and get V2.0 out as soon as I can, but I do have a variety of other things on the go as well.
P.S. Yes, I know. Since she divorced Weasley #3, I would think that she would revert to her maiden name. Hence, Hermione Granger Boot Seino Gough Bouvier Terwilliger Hutz McClure Weasley Weasley Weasley Granger.
P.P.S. They wre in Vegas, what more do you really need? |
| |
minerdudeSigned | Chapter : 4 | Date : 17/03/08
Good story. nice ref to the Simpsons, although some names I did not get. |
Author Feedback: That's because most of the names are surnames of people I know. I'd frankly be rather surprised if you knew them. |
| |
Harry85Signed | Chapter : 4 | Date : 17/03/08
Well, yes it was kind of quick, but I liked it all the same, so good job here |
Author Feedback: Yea, it really was. Well, like I said, it will probably be revamped at some point.
Glad you liked it though, honestly. |
| |
|
Ok...why exactly did Harry leave Hermione again? Please don't tell me it was the noble hero b.s. cliche.
This really wasn't explained all that well...and I think it was pretty central to understanding the characters.
~Matt |
Author Feedback: Okay, then I won't.
That was a bad joke, I'm sorry.
To be honest, I kind of left it up to interpretation accidentally on purpose. It isn't necessarily a good thing to lead readers by the hand, I don't think. |
| |
PMidNiteSigned | Chapter : 3 | Date : 18/02/08
Another good chapterI'm glad they are hooking back up, Harry with all that bs leaving Hermione like that, But hopefully all will end well.
PapaMidNite |
| |
Harry85Signed | Chapter : 3 | Date : 18/02/08
Well, I liked ths chapter. Although, Harry's stupidity back when he broke her heart is something huge, you know. |
Author Feedback: Agreed. But really, there are only so many things he could have said that would have made Hermione leave him. I think the other one is 'I am gay,' and even that's a little iffy |
| |
AnonymousUnsigned | Chapter : 3 | Date : 17/02/08
I liked it. I can't wait for the epilogue, to see how everything turns out. |
| |
KatUnsigned | Chapter : 3 | Date : 17/02/08
Aww... I don't want this fic to be over, it was too good. I'll be looking for your next story though. |
Author Feedback: Well thank you Kat.
If you liked this, I have two more WIP's sitting around. Harry85's Secret Wizards is a good choice too. |
| |
|
oh please dont get me wrong, while i do critique the way that you had ti all play out, i do genuinley enjoy how you always take me off gaurd with your choice of route- even if it may not be my fav you at least do soemthign that few have ever done, and your prose is fantastic
i'd recommend that if you do choose to rewrite it (which'd also be great lol) then you do it as another version rather than totally deleting this one
it'd be really cool to have both of these options out as they are well-writen and there's nothign REALLY faultyt with either one |
Author Feedback: hmm, that's a good idea. And one I'd never have thought of. Thanks! |
| |
AnonymousUnsigned | Chapter : 3 | Date : 17/02/08
Hermione is making it to easy for Harry. He hurt her badly and betrayed her trust and heart. I don't think she should so easily be letting him back in. Instead she should be making him earn her back and I have yet to see any real remorse from Harry at the pain he caused her. I love Harry and Hermione but so far I am having a hard time feeling that Harry deserves to have her. However, I have hopes that as the story progresses I will be changing my mind. |
Author Feedback: Yea, she really is isn't she?
Best I can describe it: Hermione knows she shouldn't be crumbling so easily, (which she states quite clearly) but she can't help herself. Despite everything that has happened, she is falling in love with the man who broke her heart. She doesn't know why, he sure as hell doesn't know why, but it's happening.
I dunno, I just can't find it within me to keep them apart. Even in the fic that was purely me, with no challenges involved whatsoever, they get together in the third chapter. I guess I just suffer from extreme fluffiness.
As for Harry's lack of remorse, he spent ten years as a detective specializing in manslaughter. As I mentioned in one of the flashbacks last chapter, he deals with an unbelievable amount of crime. He has learnt to detach himself from his emotions, a little too well I'm afraid. He really is sorry, but he's forgotten how to express it. Another downside to his loveless marriage. |
| |
|