LOGIN PANEL :

Displaying Reviews for
The Anatomy of a Love Affair

Total Reviews: 28

View chapters for a specific chapter:

<< prev
jump   |
fenriswolf
Signed | Chapter : 1 | Date : 09/08/07
This is the only acceptable way for an affairfic between Harry and Hermione to end, with them telling their respective spouses the truth, divorcing and then marrying.

So many people forget a simple truth when they envisage the 'secret affair so we don't hurt our spouses' scenario. Above and beyond the fact that Harry and Hermione are too effing honorable to keep living a lie once they realize their true feelings, they would be doing something worse than cheating on their partners. By staying in loveless marriages they would be denying Ron and Ginny the chance to find someone who actually loves them the way they believe their current spouses do. That way everyone, including the children, get cheated over the long haul. So all in all, a good example of one of my less favorite genres.
 

sakura_txell
Signed | Chapter : 1 | Date : 09/08/07
I don't like affair fics either, but I have to read yours, because, honestly, you are an awesome writer. I understand that being Harmonians, after DH, we have to use thiese methods to keep our ship alive. But well, that doesn't mean we have to like them. If JKR, after OOTP, had continued the story as it should have, we wouldn't have to write affair fics (I like the stories better when Ron and Ginny die after the epilogue or even before).

However, you deserve the biggest congratulations ever for keeping our ship alive and filling our days with your always wonderful stories.

sakura_txell
 

gryffindor-girl
Signed | Chapter : 1 | Date : 09/08/07
Great, nicely written
That should be tucked in to DH after the =cough= epilogue for me because as soon as I finished the epilogue I was like... sooo, they're totally jumping each other behind R and G's back? What other explanation can there be? lol
Nice descriptions and flow is very easy to read
 

shshsh
Signed | Chapter : 1 | Date : 09/08/07
Look where JKR left us ... we have to resort to affair fics to satisfy this ... you outrageous woman.

Continue the good work and keep on posting smut fics !
 

pstibbons
Signed | Chapter : 1 | Date : 09/08/07
Nice. Inadequate Weasley hurting though. Could you up that a tad next time?
 

Christina_Potter
Signed | Chapter : 1 | Date : 09/08/07
oh my... as always, i love it well done, please make another chapter, a child would be wonderful, i know it is dificult since they already have with the other two but it would be so beautiful well done, that was just brilliant as always
Author Feedback: Sorry; I'm afraid I have no plans to write any more of this; it was meant to be a one-shot and it'll stay that way.
As for kids-- well, obviously, H/Hr will have them but honestly, all of my affair fics happen before H/G and R/Hr have any kids. I flat-out refuse to write an affair fic where they have kids (partly because I refuse to use the canon names and because the idea of H/G and R/Hr kids makes me sick but mostly because the only way I can stomach affair!fics and divorce is if kids aren't involved. Divorces-- especially messy ones and H/G and R/Hr would be supremely messy-- screw kids up too much and I can't imagine H/Hr doing that.)

Thanks for reading and reviewing.
 

usha88
Signed | Chapter : 1 | Date : 09/08/07
That was lovely. So heartbreaking. I'm quite sad that it had to end the friendship, but I don't think how something likethat could be reconciled. I'm not a big fan of affair fics, like I've said before, but it's always interesting to read.
 

ssm1122
Signed | Chapter : 1 | Date : 09/08/07
I wish that I had your muse. I just get to live vicariously through reading the stories. Another wonderful one.
 

Cateagle
Signed | Chapter : 1 | Date : 09/08/07
That's definitely a poignant, but ultimately happy, story. I did think it good that they were upfront and honest with Ron and Ginny and didn't try to hide anything. I suspect there was quite the scandal over this, and that neither Potter will be welcome at the Burrow for a long, long time to come (not sure if they'll consider this good, bad, or simply a bit sad). It was quite the well written story and I did enjoy it.
 

icemice
Unsigned | Chapter : 1 | Date : 09/08/07
Its endearingly sad yet the hhrness of it is hauntingly lovely. And I guess only an hhr fanfic writer could do it, and with amazing finesse at that. Thanks for a wonderful fic. A balm to the wearied soul is what this fic offers.
 

vlbuehle
Signed | Chapter : 1 | Date : 09/08/07
I hate affair fics, I truly detest them. When I read, half the time I want something I can escape into for a while, and affair fics are too *real* for that. And yet, for some reason, I love your affair fics. It makes no sense, but I really do love them all. This one...I hurt for Ron and Harry and Hermione, but I was glad too, because you made it so *right* that they be together. The part about the death knell of their friendship made me wince, but the ending made it worth even that loss. Great story!
 

gingercat
Unsigned | Chapter : 1 | Date : 09/08/07
Sorry they had to hurt other people, but Harry and Hermione are meant to be together.

Too bad they didn't see that before they married the other two. I know JKR put the screws to all this. What a mess she made. I can't even finish the book........too much fighting. I was one of the people who went right to the back of the book

At least they all lived.
 

SummrMagic
Signed | Chapter : 1 | Date : 09/08/07
awww! stupid ron... but it ended up the right way after all !
 

<< prev
jump   |
 

Page generated in 0.00961 seconds. 158 users currently online.
Server running: Portkey Version 2, coded by James & Skinned by Imran(NAPPA).