usha88Signed | Chapter : 16 | Date : 20/06/07
It's FINISHED!!!  How unbelievebly awesome for the ending. Wow-o-wow that made me sad. I'm so glad that he had closure. I wonder if Harry really feels like that on the day of Halloween. I mean, something has always happened on that day in tehb ooks, at least, taht I can remember.
Lovely job at the ending of this. I really liked it. |
Author Feedback: Hi usha, yeah, I took a little license with Harry feeling sad on Halloween. But as he grows older, I would think that he would have some strong feelings of empathy for his parents - especially once he grew older than they ever got to be...
Thanks for all the comments, they were so great to read. |
| |
|
I'm sorry that the story had to end. It was a very enjoyable read. I really like how you worked in the death of James and Lilly into something that really negatively impacts Harry. So many stories just seem to gloss over it. Thanks again for a good read and I hope to read more of your works later! |
Author Feedback: I'm so glad that you enjoyed it, and thank you for leaving reviews. |
| |
tard_288Signed | Chapter : 16 | Date : 20/06/07
 The end is finally here...  Another great chapter hummingbird. I want to take the time to tell you that I have thoroughly enjoyed your story. The pacing and mood setting of your story were soo good. It is hard to put into words. The feelings you envoked and the images that come to mind when reading your story gave me such a peaceful feeling. I hope that you will continue to write more and more so that the rest of us can enjoy..
Onto this chapter... Your versions of Hermione and Harry feel so real to me. It feels like I have really gotten to know them well after reading your story. Hermione was so unsure of herself and Harry's words described her perfectly:
"Hermione Granger was brave enough to pull bold stunts, and smart enough to realize when they were needed. But, Harry reflected, as he stood there paralyzed by his own ancient daemons, she had a fragile ego. And right now he was shattering it."
It took alot of nerve for Hermione to try something like this and it shows how much she cares and loves him. It is good that Harry has finally faced his own demons as he has helped so many in the past face theirs. Finally our hero is allowed to be happy and leave all of the sorrow and hardships of his childhood behind. Hermione has finaly helped him achieve closure.
I still think you are 'funny' Hermione.
“Shush,” Hermione answered, pretending to be annoyed. “Don't mock my idea of a hot date in front of the dead. It's bad luck.”
Truly looking forward to reading more of your work. I have you set as one of favorite authors so I will be alerted whenever you post something. |
Author Feedback: Tard - what can I say? Your reviews are way too kind, but they always made me smile - you have a really neat way of putting things! I'm thrilled, too, that you like Hermoine's dorky kind of humor - I love that kind of thing, and I was initially very nervous that everyone would crinkle their nose at her lines.
Thank you so much for reading this and leaving your impressions. |
| |
That was awesome! I'll tell you something though, I was so not expecting this fic to end just yet. I swear to God, when I saw "the End" I did a double take. Oh well, as they say..all good things must come to an end...  I loved every moment of this fic. Your words were moving and the characters were spot on. This one is defenitely going on my favorites list! |
Author Feedback: Harrynmione - awe, thank you. I will some day read this through, and see if I can make the end not sneak up like that! It's too hard for me to see right now, but in a couple of months, I'm sure I can find a way to make it smoother!
Thanks again for commenting and reviewing, you are so nice to have done that. |
| |
SochSigned | Chapter : 16 | Date : 19/06/07
I dunno - that last chapter was a bummer! I get him being down on Oct 31st (although he wasn't ever particularly down about it in Cannon - there was always a big feats), but this angsty cowardly things... it's over the top.
This story took a sharp turn in the last chapter, and that was pretty cool, but it kept on turning into this one and that wasn't nearly as enjoyable. The whole story is about Harry and Hermione getting together 8 years after the fall of Mouldyshorts, but then you end it with a chapter about Harry dealing with his parents being dead. If this were a chapter in the middle of the story, I could credit it more, but you ENDED the story with it, and it's just a jarring change from the flow.
I'm sorry if I sound harsh, but I will remind you that really loved the story up to here.
Thank you for sharing it with us, and keep up the good work! |
Author Feedback: This story is actually about what the title states: closure. You may have assumed that it was about Harry and Hermione getting together, but that was just one of the issues. Hermione needs direction and purpose and love, the Muggle world needs answers and to be set at ease, Harry needs to confront lots of things: his past among them. These two have found that they have the unique capabiity of being able to help each other in very important ways, and this - I like to think, anyway - will be very helpful in their future as well as they travel through life together.
I will be very interested to see if more folks out there are dissiappointed or surprised by the ending...
|
| |
That was a really excellent chapter. You've such a nice way of setting up the ending... I loved the fact that the two of them come together, really, as Harry professes his love to Hermione and then faces his parents' graves. That was extraordinarily well done and you should be really proud of the way you handled that.
I also appreciated alot the fact that you showed Harry coming to grips, emotionally, with the fact that he really has done some amazing things and that his parents _would_ have been proud of him. That was a great paragraph!
SO - Huge thumbs-up to you. This is a five-star chapter (out of four stars).
Regards,
the_scribbler |
Author Feedback: Thank you for the elequent reviews, I love to read them. This chapter seems to have come out of left field for some readers, but was where I wanted to head all along, so I may have mislead a few folks along the way! Anyway, thank you so much - I can't tell you how encouraging and gratifying it is to see that this fic has gotten lots of hits and then to read the reviews has always been such a terrific bonus.
|
| |
CateagleSigned | Chapter : 16 | Date : 19/06/07
Ohh, a very nic wrap-up. I think Hermione took a brave, but necessary, step there with Harry and it appears to have had a big payoff. I suspect she's going to be quite surprised by the Harry she meets on the morrow. It looks like the two of them are bonding intensely on all levels. From this point, I wonder how long 'til he asks for her hand. |
Author Feedback: I'm thinking a year. They've got everything worked out, it'll just be a matter of when they start thinking along those lines. Maybe a year is too much, but they should be free to just have fun and play and really get to know each other before the dreaded wedding plans take them over!
|
| |
AnonymousUnsigned | Chapter : 16 | Date : 19/06/07
A very poignant and touching ending. I agree with Harry's assesment of closure, not only for him but for us the readers. You did a great job showing and leading his gradual acceptance of himself and finding his closure.
You have a talent for writing and I hope to be able to read more of your stories. You definitely will only get better with time and practice like fine wine. |
Author Feedback:
Thank you "anaymous reviewer"! Your words are so very encouraging, and it really means a lot! |
| |
Awww.  Perfectly sweet, with just the right amount of emotion. And I too find it weird that Harry has never gone to their graves/memorials/something else like that. Or maybe he has and JKR has not written about it... |
Author Feedback: Thanks nakedquidditchfan, and cute name by the way. Is it in reference to the hilarioius fic that I read a year or so ago? Anyway, thank you again for the helpful and kind comments - I wonder whether JK will have him visit his parents in DH - I kind of think so, don't you? We shall see soon.
|
| |
AnonymousUnsigned | Chapter : 16 | Date : 19/06/07
epilouge? or that all of it? nice ending, but don't leave us hanging |
Author Feedback: I'm coming around to that idea, thanks for the review! |
| |
telmieSigned | Chapter : 16 | Date : 19/06/07
Nothing in this moment, I repeat, nothing in this moment describe the emotion I feel, in my heart, when I read this story, specially this chapter.
I´m a little spechless. If you observe, this is the first review that I wrote. I couldn´t. I try so many times, but I couldn´t. The emotion, after read each chapter was so high, that i could not write a review. It´s silly to say this, but it´s true.
I put your story like my favourite, because, it´s the better, because this one capture my heart in the first moment.
Congratulations, thanks, nothing is suficient to THANK YOU.
You wrote Harry and Hermione the way, I believe, each portkey fan and others around the world who, one day, will read this, the way we believe this two LOVE, COMPLETE, CARE, for each other.
No one should doubt this.
I hope you will continue write beautiful stories, like this one. It´s inspirational.
and I hope you will post some epilogue or continue this one, who knows.
God bless your inteligence e sensibility.
hugs,
telma. |
Author Feedback: Telmie,
You are very sweet to say such things. I have much to learn, and so pleased that you were able to enjoy my first shot at writing. I'm not young, but I've never written anyting nontechnical before, so this is kind of new and fun. I like the way you write in your reviews - it's kind of poetic. |
| |
tard_288Signed | Chapter : 15 | Date : 19/06/07
Another great chapter hummingbird!! I really enjoy the way you always seem to have Hermione debating with herself in her own mind. I sometimes wish that JKR would write a chapter from Hermione's perspective.
Ron makes another appearance and the story has gone back to Harry seeking his own form of closure. The little scene was Alice coming forward to Harry was really well done and thought out. I can't say that I know how she feels but the scene was very well thought out and that it feel more real.  It is too bad that neither Harry nor Hermione trusted Ron enough to tell him about their relationship sooner. Maybe the both of them are not quite use to the 'grown up mature' Ron yet. Ron from canon would have gone ballistic if he found out from a third party.  I really enjoyed the Ron/Harry scene at the leaky cauldron. The both of them really did seem like old friends getting together after a long separation. Very well done...
The last scene in Hermione's apartment was hilarious. Harry waving his wand around trying to make the time display.  Hermione once again going into her 'blaming herself' mode regarding Harry. She really needs to get over that. Very sweet nonetheless.  Drunk Harry's emotions seem to be all over the map. One moment he talking about missing his parents because it is October and then the next, he wants to 'fool around'.  Can't wait for the next chapter and see where you take this story!!! |
Author Feedback: Thank you. I do agree, Harry and Hermione need to get back in to a closer relationship with Ron though. I think I may write an epilogue to include some of that. |
| |
AnonymousUnsigned | Chapter : 15 | Date : 16/06/07
I liked this story a lot. You are a very talented writer. |
| |
usha88Signed | Chapter : 15 | Date : 15/06/07
That was an absolutely lovely chapter. I really liked it. Great job. I loved how Harry got drunk and how cute he acted. I wish I could come to a drunken Harry!! Lol.
I really enjoyed this chapter and liked that it was a little light-hearted despite the fact that Harry was undergoing all those hard times. I do wish I could see moreo f Ron and Hermione together...I mean interacting..well..the whole Trio, but I understand thsi fic is to focus on Hermione and Ron. I, like the other two, am missing Ron (in this fic). Lol.
Can't wait for your next update |
Author Feedback: Thanks Usha88,
I need to screen the last chapter - I catch a few more errors every time I read these through, and then I'll have it posted. And then I'll be so sad! This sight is really terrific and lively. |
| |
HeidiHoSigned | Chapter : 15 | Date : 15/06/07
Love "distracted" Hermione and her focus on Harry. I also love what you've done with Ron. As for Harry - poor Harry.  Such a famous boy. And hot. Anyway, excellent chapter, I can't wait to read more. |
Author Feedback: Thanks HeidiHo. There is one chaper left, and then I'll be so sad - this has been so much fun to post and "watch" people read.... I'm so glad you liked Ron, and I wish that I'd have included him more... |
| |
|