LOGIN PANEL :

Displaying Reviews for
January

Total Reviews: 276

View chapters for a specific chapter:

jump   | next >>
ladylaughalot
Signed | Chapter : 19 | Date : 14/07/08
Don't mind me just adding this to my list of favourites
Author Feedback:

I do mind Thank you, it's nice to be on favourites lists.

Ama
 

HarrysAngel
Signed | Chapter : 11 | Date : 25/05/08
I've been reading this since last night. Always intending to leave a review at the end. I've gotten so caught up, wanting to read each new chapter. It's amazing. The whole idea of magic waning or running out intrigues me. And of course, HHr.

I can't wait to read the rest. However, I felt I wanted to leave one here because something in this chapter caught my attention. And I smiled. The use of the surname, Cruddens. If you remove the 's' at the end, it becomes Crudden. My mom's maiden name. It thought it was kinda neat to see it there in print. Anyway, awesome story. Please, keep up the great work.
Author Feedback:

Hi, I'm very late, but I just wanted to say thank you. I hope you enjoyed it all.

Ama
 

Victoria Tonks
Signed | Chapter : 17 | Date : 23/04/08
I had no idea your Fred went this far. A very interesting take, though.

My fav parts of this chapter? "“Ron!” She grins. She steals a glance at Harry and finds she can’t bear the expression on his face. Slowly, he walks up to the bike and sits down next to her. A little far, as if he wouldn’t dare come close, he might break it all apart again. He looks so young, like they were starting all over again, back in the train to Hogwarts." Oh boy.

And Ron? "It’s like watching my parents doing it!” And to think, he might've been written a bit like that in canon. He did have potential. *heavy sigh*

(and sorry for those pathetic attempts at reviews, I'm completely out of practice )
Author Feedback:

Replying so late to reviews should be made illegal, gah. Sorry J, something odd going on with my PK alerts, I don't get all of them on email. Anyway, just thought I'd say thanks. Hope you enjoyed till the end.
Ama
 

Victoria Tonks
Signed | Chapter : 16 | Date : 23/04/08
Your Ron is . I loved it how he was able to take control of everything. And he's so protective of his friends. Ahhhhh.

'Tis also good to know more about what really happened in the previous chapter.
 

Victoria Tonks
Signed | Chapter : 15 | Date : 22/04/08
OMG, what a chapter. What a chapter. Yes, I know it's not a real review. *runs off to read the next one*
 

Victoria Tonks
Signed | Chapter : 10 | Date : 18/04/08
Just re-reading the whole story because I need to know it all afresh to go on - and oh, can I say how much I your Harry and Hermione? Harry's pain when he thought Hermione was leaving for good is almost tangible. Oh boy. He needs her badly indeed!
 

Ripley
Unsigned | Chapter : 4 | Date : 13/03/08
Your descriptions are wonderful! It's just enough to give the feeling of the scene without bogging down the narrative with angst and desperation. I'm really enjoying this story.
Author Feedback:
Thank you, I hope you continue to enjoy.

Ama
 

AnnF
Signed | Chapter : 2 | Date : 12/02/08
So AU to DH? Fred alive instead of George, Snape alive too, and Draco not giving up on killing Harry?
 

ears91
Signed | Chapter : 19 | Date : 04/01/08
Lovely story.. yes took me forever to finally read it, got caught up in school work, then just kept putting it off and letting it pile in my inbox(till now, winter break). I think I rather prefer it this way, yes the possible end of magic, but a reunion between them all.. Again, Fantastic story!
Author Feedback:

Hi, thank you so much. Glad it all seems to make sense in the end!
Ama
 

tubin
Signed | Chapter : 19 | Date : 02/01/08
OK, that was a good epilogue. I was a little worried it would be a JKR-style epi with marriages and kids twenty years out... totally fluffy and inappropriate for the rest of the story. Instead it puts an exclamation point on the reasons for ending the story where you did.

You write beautifully. Thank you for creating this story.
Author Feedback:

Thank you so much for sticking by, I really appreciate all the reviews you've left. I know it was hard to get into but I'm so glad the story worked out for you in the end. And the epilogue and Ron (as you mentioned in a previous review) were two of the most pleasurable parts to write, so I'm very happy they made sense! Thanks again for reading and reviewing.
Ama
 

tubin
Signed | Chapter : 18 | Date : 02/01/08
I wouldn't have thought this was a good place to end it - the magic question still unanswered, relationships with Weasleys, Nick still unclear - but oddly, it is. The key players in the story have come out of a time of stasis and indecision, and started actively planning for the future again. And because we have faith in the characters, we believe they'll manage to create a good future. I'll go read the epilogue but I'm not even sure one is needed...
 

tubin
Signed | Chapter : 17 | Date : 02/01/08
Usually I'm not very fond of Ron. As JKR writes him, he's insensitive and selfish, hardly to be counted on to do the right thing at any given time. Your Ron, though - I'm half in love with him. He manages to use his goofiness to lighten the moment at just the right time, he holds people together, he's reliably loyal. Seems like it's only because of Ron that Mrs. Weasley, Ginny, and Fred still have anything to do with Harry and Hermione.
 

tubin
Signed | Chapter : 16 | Date : 02/01/08
OK, more becomes clear now.

Hard to believe the St. Mungo's people could get Grimwald place fully clean and bright when Mrs Weasley worked so hard (with a crew of kids to help her) and couldn't manage it for even one or two rooms.
 

tubin
Signed | Chapter : 15 | Date : 02/01/08
That was action-packed and cliff-hanger-y. The imagery is very good - confusion, panic, more confusion. Of course, I have no idea what's going on, just like the main characters - I'm taking it on faith that it'll become clear later?
 

auser
Signed | Chapter : 19 | Date : 19/12/07
I finally finished this today and now I have a sort of sad feeling, because I liked anticipating new chapters. But putting aside my childish desire for things I like to go on forever, I think you ended it at exactly the right point. It would not have matched the tone of your story to end with everyone being completely happy, nor everyone being miserable. You've maintained a careful balance throughout the story and the ending was a perfect reflection of that.

Good luck with your own writing. You have a unique voice and I suspect you could have success if you stick with it.
Author Feedback:

Thank you--to say that I ended at exactly the right point is so good to hear. And thanks for your well-wishes, we'll see!

Ama
 

jump   | next >>
 

Page generated in 0.01032 seconds. 252 users currently online.
Server running: Portkey Version 2, coded by James & Skinned by Imran(NAPPA).