great job. i loved this story so much.  i cant wait to read the rest of your stories.
|
| |
lorelSigned | Chapter : 6 | Date : 09/10/07
Very well done. Good job. I have enjoyed this and you other fics as well . Good luck in all of your endeavors. |
| |
GiringiroSigned | Chapter : 6 | Date : 09/10/07
I wanted to thank you for your lovely stories on Portkey. Powers of Persuasion, The Littlest Things and Another Witch are three favourites of mine.
To be fair, I didn't like this last one much. The main characters (Harry, Hermione and Elisabeth) felt off-key, they behaved somewhat erratically, and gave weak explanations for their actions in the story, and for their past and present feelings.
(you warned me in my previous review I might feel the ending is a cop-out. I do, a bit. There's no real reason for Elisabeth being unwilling to work things out with Harry, or for Harry falling for Hermione out of the blue after so many years of never considering her)
I wouldn't agree with Hermione about not changing anything, just because she got what she wanted. It strikes me she did nothing noteworthy at all but got extremely lucky, first with Elisabeth's last second cold feet and then with Harry's change of mind about her. Her nobility/cowardice certainly didn't help anyone.
But everything was very well written and positively dramatic, and I loved your description of both marriages, from that point of view the last two chapters were a joy to read.
I hope I'll read something of you again some day.
Thanks thanks thanks!
|
| |
|
what a lovely ending to a lovely story. sad to see you're leaving Portkey but I guess if its time to move on. great reading your stories. all the best. |
| |
AnonymousUnsigned | Chapter : 6 | Date : 09/10/07
Bravo and Encoure!
I really enjoyed this. Very nice and sweet.
|
| |
Tank03Signed | Chapter : 6 | Date : 09/10/07
Bravo! Lots to like about this chapter. I'm glad things came back to the necklace, I had a feeling that it would prove to be important.
I suspected Elizabeth was the one to object but I also had a feeling Harry may have put a stop to things. No matter, it worked out well.
I'm glad that things didn't immediately jump to happy ever after, that would have been a bit too unrealistic. He was left at the alter after all, I have to believe that takes some getting over, regardless of his feelings for Hermione. I think the fact that so much time passed following the Elizabeth's exit before they got together is one of the best parts of this story. Well done.
I wasn't aware that this would be your last story. I'm certainly going to miss reading new stuff from you and I hope your absence proves to be a vacation and not a permanent departure. In any event, I'll still continue to reread your works here at Portkey. They continue to provide great entertainment and I can't thank you enough for sharing them with us.
Best of luck and thank you. |
| |
MaDeLaiNeSigned | Chapter : 6 | Date : 09/10/07
Hey!
Would I sound like a stupid if I tell you that I was sure it was Elizabeth? LOL.. Lucky guess, I think, but it made sense. It wasn't going to be Harry -too honorable- nor hermione -same- nor any of their friends. So it only left ELizabeth herself.
I love this last chapter. But I'm not sure about Harry after the wedding fiasco, and at risk of sounding silly, I want to be sure, lol.
The night before the wedding (elizabeths one) is Harry in love with Hermione already? I got a yes, from his open question. And I can't believe he did nothing for 18 months! Was he in love with Hemrione all this time, or was he feeling horrible because Elizabeth had left? Ok, I read that he seemed to not refuse the reasons she explained to not marry him, but I just want to be sure, lol. I'm especially slow today.
*sighs* I guess I need reassurance, given how wonderful Elizabeth was for him
hugs!
PS: I added you to my livejournal friends (Miss_Bela)
|
| |
AnonymousUnsigned | Chapter : 5 | Date : 09/10/07
That was just plain old mean...lol. You had me on the first chapter, and can't wait to read what happens next...hopefully it won't be too long of a wait. Keep up the good work, and God Bless!! |
| |
|
My bet's on Elizabeth saying it. I don't think Harry would to that, and Ginny and Ron would be smart enough to back off. |
Author Feedback: Well I guess we'll see how up to scratch your powers of deduction in the next chapter, up soon! Thanks for reading! |
| |
perdita5Signed | Chapter : 5 | Date : 06/10/07
Don't bother about this chapter not having any flashbacks, I loved it anyway  I'm sooo looking forward to what's going to happen next and who the hell objected, I can't wait to read more! I love it! |
Author Feedback: I should update pretty soon. Thanks for reading! |
| |
|
Ahh what a cliffhanger!! Ughh but thats ok cuz I loved the chapter, I can't wait for the next update to see who spoke up. Love the story and write more soon! |
Author Feedback: I  cliffies! I willupdate pretty soon. Thanks for reading! |
| |
LineanUnsigned | Chapter : 5 | Date : 03/10/07
NOOOO!!!! don't stop!!! who said it? who said it?!?!? the suspense is killing me!! ahhhhhhhhhhhh!!!!
Love this story by the way- very well written.
~Linean |
Author Feedback: Glad you're enjoying it! I will update very soon. Thanks for reading! |
| |
SummerUnsigned | Chapter : 5 | Date : 03/10/07
ah come on!!!!!!!!!! that left me hanging big time!!!! who is it gonna be???? i think it's ron. oh, no! maybe elizabeth!!! update soon! |
Author Feedback: All the guesses I'm reading make cliffies worth writing. I wil update soon so you know for sure! |
| |
ivyUnsigned | Chapter : 5 | Date : 03/10/07
Oh, you are so evil!!!! Please please update soon!...I think it's Harry..., nope, he's too noble...Elizabeth? Because she mustn't be THAT clueless...hehehehe Please please, I implore you, update soon!!!! I don't mind whether the next one is twice as long or just two paragraphs (hehehe), just update soon! |
Author Feedback: I am getting called all sorts of names in the reviews for this chapter! And to answer your pleas, I will update very soon. And I hope you will enjoy the final chapter! Thanks for reading! |
| |
gakSigned | Chapter : 5 | Date : 03/10/07
I tossed and turned all night, mostly due to a cold, but I found myself thinking about your story over and over again. I love it when a story stays with me. Your ability to create compassion and frustration is quite good. I look forward to the next chapter. |
Author Feedback: Wow, thanks so much, I'm glad you're enjoying the story. I hope you're better by now. I will be updating soon, so be on the lookout! |
| |
|