newynSigned | Chapter : 1 | Date : 27/08/09
Lovely, just lovely.
Harry confessing to having already read the story beforehand created an extra layer to the story. It made it more than the usual, cliched common room flirting. It suddenly opens up a whole new range of possible explanations for his unusually forward behavior.
There is a reversal of roles. Suddenly, Harry is revealed as the participant who goes into this encounter with the bigger secrets to reveal. Hermione, who starts out as having a big crush to hide, becomes the innocent participant who has surprises sprung on her.
Intended or not, all the parts work to enrich the layering. Even the NC-17 talk has more to it than meets the eye. It turns out to be a red herring, a prop Harry uses to push Hermione out of her comfort zone and set her up for the big revelation.
The comedown from the hints of smutty goodness is a downer. But the tradeoff is excellent. The ending is a refreshing rendering of harmony realized.
Kudos to you! |
| |
|
great fic ... i love it when people add an element of the mundane into the universe |
| |
|
I have read 'The seventh Scroll' a while ago, and I loved it. And I loved this story.
I hope to read more stories from you very soon.
Sakura_txell |
| |
RicciUnsigned | Chapter : 1 | Date : 23/08/06
Thank you for writing this fic. I needed something to read this summer and after reading your story, I decided to try out Smith's Egyptian series. I got them from the library but about half way through The Seventh Scroll, I decided to go ahead and buy them. You're right, Smith is an amazing author. I absolutly fell in love with Taita. Are his other series as good?
Thanks again, and keep up the good work! |
| |
I enjoyed that! I love cheeky Harry & romantic Hermione. |
| |
luv4booksUnsigned | Chapter : 1 | Date : 09/07/06
|
| |
|
XD This made me laugh. Quite a bit. The thought of Harry catching her reading a smutty book XD well a somewhat smutty book...is just amusing. I really liked everything, even Harry's questions and the whole thing was sweet. Made me smile when I wasn't laughing. XD I really did like the idea, I read your summary and grinned, knowing it'd be good, which it was! Muchly so. |
| |
AnonymousUnsigned | Chapter : 1 | Date : 03/07/06
I loved it!!!!!!Oh my god. You know I really like how the book sounds. The Seventh Scroll looks like a book I wouldn't mind reading.Well I'm gona go see some more of your other story's bye! |
| |
Harry seemed soo clueless at the start- what a little actor. Very, very, very, very good 
It's fics like that which I love ^.^
L8RZ,
Spyro |
| |
cheeky, smart, funny,.. i liked it!!  this was teh first of one of ur stories i ead so im hoping the rest are just as good, which no doubt they will be  |
| |
khush51Signed | Chapter : 1 | Date : 22/06/06
why did it have to end so fast. hmm.. I was enjoying it. lol. It was a very original idea for a fanfic and that was refreshing. keep up the adorable love stories. It makes my days go faster when I read them. |
| |
u should have put "marks" around read that would have fitted this story lol lots of love though i like it alot  |
| |
|
It was very good.
I just had one question. They had to be in their eventh year because you said her parent's bought her it in the summer before her seventh year and she was still at hogwarts. I was just a little confused at that part.
I liked how you kept true to the characters. Harry being curious and somewhat oblivious to what was going on. I really did enjoy it.
"Sucking on nipples,” he said, in a matter-of-factly voice."
lmao
|
| |
oh, it's so sweet  please carry on writing... I find your style very natural and almost identical to the books.
and the plot line is so very unique, it makes people smile when they read it. |
| |
Bloody fantastic, as usual. 
You've got talent.. there's no doubt about it.
Am I the only one waiting for a R or more rated fic from u?  ( will there ever be one?) xD |
| |
|