good ending leave it for the reader to decide... sometimes this type of ending can be better than when there is closure or w.e

I don't know about anyone else, but I loved "The Lady or the Tiger". Trying to figure out the ending really helps give insight into one's own heart and motivations.

Just Like This.

Did Harry follow the path of vengeance, or did he allow the good in him to step forward at the end? I rather like to believe that he would follow his conscience than the hate within him. Great work Calmacil20.

******************
Holly Wood and Vine: where magic is sure to happen

what the hell was that?!?why did you stop!?! we readers are not even sure what he's decided to do!!you're going to make a sequel..right??

Ok, first of all, I wanna say that this story is great, and your writing is awesome. However, I really don't like ending. It leaves you guessing, and you don't know whether Harry killed Pettigrew or not. And if he did, who did kill him? There needs to be an epilogue or something that gives the story closure. Other than that, great story, and keep up the good work!

husker_fan_2006

All I have to say is that I wish that you wouldn't have finished that way. I think that you should add more because it doesn't give your readers closure and that makes them a little mad.

YOU CANT DO THAT!!!

Update Immediately if not sooner!!

*Takes deep calming breath*

Well that was a very good chapter, you really know how to work the tension don't you. Um... ah stuff it... UPDATE!!!

Is this like the lady and the tiger thing?

That was great. Very emotional. But I have to agree with a lot of the other reviewers. The ending was just so off. You built this all around how Harry felt about Peter being caught and then when it became that he would be the one to give Peter his sentence. It's really not fair to the readers to leave it like that. After all the build up to that moment it was a let down.

Great story, but the ending is a cop-out. Yes, we get the notion that he did not execute PP himself. But, the question still remains, who did? The question of how PP meets his end, is as much importance to the story that the possible romance is.

wh-what?? why did u stop? nooooooooo now we will never know what he did, even though i'm pretty sure he chooses to stop, and go with Hermione...right?? loll
well it was well written and it kept my attention! great job! cant wait to see more of your work.

I applaud your writing skills; this is a very well-written story. However, I personally hate stories that leave you guessing--they tend to leave a bad taste in my mouth, and I tend to get a negative feeling about them. With that in mind, I don't have much to say about it in either a constructive or destructive manner.

wait.... is this the end? it said complete in the summary thing... you cant end it here! one more chapter is needed! HHr fluff is needed
Luke

Ooooohh! I can't wait for the next one - there is going to be a next one isn't there??

He can't do it! He just can't!

I usually don't review stories but PLEASE don't leave us hanging!!!!!! You can't end it there!!!Are you writting a sequal?

Thanks
ravensinclaire

That was a great story! I loved your characterizations and a really unique plot idea.

To be honest I would have prefered a more definitive ending. I thought that up until the last minute that it was still 50/50 as to what he would do. I especially would have liked to see his interaction with Hermione after having made his choice, and upon their arrival home. Not that I'm looking for fluff or smut, but I would have liked to see the conversation that took place. Hermione was so adamant that killing Pettigrew was wrong that she was willing to let go of the love of her life. That kind of passion surely must have led to an interestingly deep discussion. Perhaps an epilogue?

Anyway, that's just me. You really did a cracking job on this and it was a pleasure to read it. Thanks for sharing! I'm looking forward to reading more of your stuff in the future.