This is a really nice story. Really sweet how much they care for each other and how they practically think the same. I think it's a perfect timing to tell Hermione how he feels. Just before they go on a journey that might do a lot of harm. Very awesome! |
| |
AnonymousUnsigned | Chapter : 1 | Date : 29/01/06
the story was gret but i hope there will be a second part of it. continue doing a great story like this. |
| |
|
ok, the beggining was preety good, but the end where they admited their feelings was just stupid
rework the end |
Author Feedback: Why did you think the ending was stupid? I'm just curious, maybe I can fix it up to make it not 'stupid'. |
| |
|
Nice title, very fitting! So, we all know that H/Hr is inevitable at portkey, and Ginny seemed to take it so well, but will it be so easy for Ron? I guess I'll have to wait and see! |
Author Feedback: Lol! Oh, I have so many ideas for how Ron could take the news.... |
| |
alayneniSigned | Chapter : 1 | Date : 17/01/06
Nice story. It will be interesting to see where you take it from here. The possiblities are endless! |
Author Feedback: Lol!  I wasn't even sure if I wanted to make this a chaptered story... what do you think? |
| |
|
Wow! Fast-paced as in the feelings change so fast! I think they should remain friends at least a little longer! just my opinion..
|
Author Feedback: Hmm.... did it seem that fast-paced? Well, for now, they are just friends who have admitted that they liked each other... I'm not even sure if I'm going to keep adding chapters to this or if I just want to make it a one-shot.  But thanks for your opinion! |
| |
sweet and fluffy.... although I felt like it was a bit abrupt.... I guess when you're gonna be part of a big battle between good and evil you tend to hasten up a bit.but none the less I love the nice butterfly feel it gives me... |
Author Feedback: Lol! Did it feel abrupt? I kind of had a rush of ideas and I wasn't sure what to put and what not to put in, but I'm happy with how it came out. Thanks so much for the review! |
| |
usha88Unsigned | Chapter : 1 | Date : 17/01/06
|
Author Feedback: Thanks so much! I was worried about the fact that going to war might not work out so well with the romance side of the fic, but apparently, it wasn't so bad! |
| |
CroixSigned | Chapter : 1 | Date : 17/01/06
 I'm all choked up inside. Beautiful. Absolutely adorable. A few grammatical errors, but easily read over because of the content. I adore it, do continue. (: |
Author Feedback: Aw, thanks so much! You've totally made my day.... I had no idea my writing can have that effect on people, especially since I'm so new to this.  Thanks again! |
| |
ilovemagicUnsigned | Chapter : 1 | Date : 17/01/06
I like it very much. It's romantic, even though they don't even kiss. Very nice. |
Author Feedback: Thanks so much! I was going for sweet, but not overly romantic, especially since I'm not so good at romance.... but I'm glad you enjoyed it! |
| |
|
I really enjoyed reading this story, but I think it's lacking backround detail. When did Harry realize his feelings for Hermione, and when did she do the same? Why does Ginny realize that Harry feels this way about Ginny? How did they break up? What happened with Ron and Hermione. I realize that Harry and Hermione shippers don't like writing about Ron and Hermione and Harry and Ginny, but for many stories, this one included, it is needed. YOu don't have to go into great detail, but the effect of these relationships changes their futures and future realationships with each other. If you are going to make reference to things like that, make sure that the reader is aware of it. There is really only one indication that Harry likes Hermione before he actually tells her how he feels.
I look forward to reading the next chapter, and keep on sailing HMS Harmony! |
Author Feedback: Thanks for the advice--you really pointed out some of the things that I was kind of debating whether I should have put into the story or not. But thanks for the opinion!  |
| |
MioneUnsigned | Chapter : 1 | Date : 17/01/06
That was a great start,this post was really good and i can't wait to read more,please post more soon |
Author Feedback: Lol! Well, I'm still not sure it I really do want to take this any further... Originally, I just wanted it to be a one-shot... But I do have a few ideas, so maybe I'll think about it. |
| |
ElivaniaSigned | Chapter : 1 | Date : 17/01/06
Um...okay...really really fast and with no real explanation as to why so many of these things are happening. Why at the grangers house? Why was it so easy for Hermione's parents to grasp the concept of her not going to school and the whole danger thing? Why and how did Harry realize his feelings and tell her so randomly. There was no build up. None. You have a good concept just expand and slow down. Writing isn't a race. Go deeper into the emotions and reasons of the characters and their actions. |
Author Feedback: I'm sorry if it seemed like I was rushing.  I'm still kind of new at this.... and I was also planning to keep this as just a one-shot, I wasn't planning on having it be chaptered. That's why I kind of rushed the plot.
But thanks for the review anyway.  It brought a lot of insight to me and my writing. |
| |
lierianSigned | Chapter : 1 | Date : 17/01/06
that was so lovely and sweet. I love the imagery in Harry's loneliness melting away in Hermione's arms! |
Author Feedback: Thanks so much!  You have no idea how much I loved that imagery, and the fact that you appreciate it too makes me feel so great! |
| |
|