hermy415Signed | Chapter : 1 | Date : 11/03/07
hey there!!! you might really think i'm dumb for saying this but i'm not really that poetic to understand the story.... i didn't get it actually... so, i was wondering if you can explain to me what happened? why it happened? and what... oh boy, my braind cells are jumbled...
anyway, i hope you'll reply to this...
I support h/hr!!!
Proud to be a Delusional Harmonian!!! |
| |
|
Oh that was so sad how they both love each other but it never happens (wipes eyes) but it was so beautiful.
Luv Ama xx |
| |
|
Sorry, it's me again. I happen to read your response to my earlier review (actually I was re-reading your story).
Just to let you know, I usually leave my review when a story touches me. Sometimes the story is happy, sometimes it is sad, but so long as it touches my heart, I usually leave a review.
So in your case, this story definitely touches me. The reason is because I have been puzzling so long over the wording of the prophecy, and I'm afraid that what you have written here might be what the prophecy really means.
I really hope it is not so, because I really want Harry to live, but the way JKR wrote the prophecy... it makes me wonder. And now your story makes me wonder some more...
|
| |
AnonymousUnsigned | Chapter : 1 | Date : 09/09/05
W.O.W. i know that the other comments on this must be along the same lines, but wow. you took one of my favorite songs, and you took my obsession with harry potter, and made them one. this is.. amazing. its written so well. Thank you for sharing this... |
| |
sherylSigned | Chapter : 1 | Date : 30/08/05
WOW!!!
That was an amazing story!!
I really liked it! i think you did a great job with it!
The resurrection was very intriguing.
This was a very well written story!!
Take care and keep it up!!!
Sheryl |
| |
|
I feel my heart goes cold reading this.
I have often tried to decipher the meaning of the prophecy, and sometimes I think it means that both Harry and Voldemort will die because of the way the prophecy is written. It seems to indicate that both of them cannot live.
But then maybe JKR is writing in disguise as she always does, so I cannot be sure. Plus, she makes Trelawney a notoriously unreliable Seer in the books, so maybe JKR would make Trelawney's prophecy erroneous in some way.
At the same time, I hope that the prophecy means, if one of them died (hopefully Voldemort) then only the other shall live a full life (hopefully Harry).
Plus, I think if JKR kills Harry in Book 7, there's going to be a global heartbreak among HP fans worldwide. I'm not sure whether that would be good for JKR as a writer. There may be backlash.
I hope Harry lives. We have enough senseless deaths in the real world and a desperate shortage of heroes to have one fictional light in our lives be killed off. |
Author Feedback: Well - not sure to take this as younot liking the story or what...but I will say that agree with you on the point of Harry dying. I also hope that it doesn't come to that. This is only something that I wanted to get out of my system, and I hope that you will read the sequel to know that everything here is not entirely what it seems. |
| |
|
wow. that is all that i can say because that was a great story. now on to reading its sequel. |
| |
Mikes652Signed | Chapter : 1 | Date : 11/08/05
DAMN, i loved your story. I really gotta reread it again to understand more of it, cause i just read tho 1 time to get most of the major parts. Well, i'm going to read that other 1 now.
Btw i rated 5.  WAS great, keep up the good work. |
| |
|
Ahhhh, what is with all the angst fics...wonderful job really, but are you trying to depress me? =) |
| |
So much emotion and oh so tragic. Guh. So sad to read of lost love. |
| |
AnonymousUnsigned | Chapter : 1 | Date : 04/08/05
omg...no....this is what I fear the most...that for Voldemort to be killed Harry has to die too..  *tear*
It's so well writen! Congratulations!! you deserve a 10! |
| |
|
Great story! Absolutely loved it! Thanks for writing and I can't wait to read more from you! |
| |
DarkPowerSigned | Chapter : 1 | Date : 04/08/05
Man, what kinda ending?! You and JK Rowling must be related, because this story has one of the most messed up endings... |
| |
 oh! my
great story, it's full of emotion and very sad. |
| |
Ok, I have one word to say about your story: sad. It was well written, but sad man....
 ,
Caity
|
| |
|