LOGIN PANEL :

Displaying Reviews for
What. An. Idiot.

Total Reviews: 22

View chapters for a specific chapter:

<< prev
jump   |
~LawOfJude~
Signed | Chapter : 1 | Date : 30/07/05
Amazing.....very beautifully written. It captured the feelings for which I have suspected Hermione has always possessed for Harry.
 

ilovemagic
Signed | Chapter : 1 | Date : 30/07/05
I like your story. I'm re-reading HBP and trying to figure out why several characters seem to be OOC. One thing I noticed that goes along with your story, is about Buckbeak. People have said Buckbeak represents Harry's love, or Harry's love for Hermione. If that's the case, Hermoione says in HBP that Buckbeak is still a bit scary (when they go to visit Hagrid the first time). He's also been renamed Witherwings so he won't be recognized. I'm betting that there will come a time when Hermione won't be scared of Buckbeak anymore, and he won't have to be called Witherwings.

While I'm re-reading, I'm also checking to see if my theory holds - that Ginny gave love potion to Harry and Hermione so she could have Harry. I think she might have given it to Hermione because everyone thought H/Hr were an item, and she refocused Hermione onto Ron. What if she put it in the water by Hermione's bed, and Lavender drank more of it than Hermione!

I'm also thinking she may have used a perfume form of love potion on Harry in the fall, because Harry only thought of her after he had been in close proximity of Ginny, and it would wear off. But I think she used a stronger potion in the spring. I'm just at the point where Harry is telling the Weasleys about Romilda's love potion, and said Slughorn could probably have slipped something into the mead without him noticing. I'll bet it's shortly after this that Ginny starts eating with the trio in the Great Hall.

I think she may have been buying potions from Verity, the new clerk in the joke shop. Her name means truth, so I think the truth will come out of her at some point, then everything can go back to normal. I'm not a writer, and I'd love to read some stories along these lines, so take the idea if you like it. We delusional H/Hr shippers have to stick together! I really do think it will be H/Hr in the end, and HBP is just a big Jane Austen type twist that Jo was shooting for.

Thanks again for the story, and keep the faith!
 

harryishot55
Signed | Chapter : 1 | Date : 29/07/05
very good. I agree that Hermione seemed OOC (but Jo is the originalcreator, and knows Hermione better than all of us) but, even though HHr is my OTP, I don't think she loves Harry over Ron... I am still only going to read HHR fics, and I won't be a RH shipper, but we all, sadly, ust face the sad, sad truth. keep pumping out those great HHr fics!
 

destroyerdrt
Signed | Chapter : 1 | Date : 29/07/05
Thank you for this story and the time and effort that you have put in to it.Please ignore any and all flames.Enjoy your self when you write and have fun in your life when you can.
 

coolman
Signed | Chapter : 1 | Date : 29/07/05
Nice fic. Te potion idea was good but could have been described better. The letter in the end was really good. Keep it up!!!
 

guardian
Signed | Chapter : 1 | Date : 29/07/05
It just makes me happy to see all these interpretations of Hermione's OOC behavior. Whatever JKR thought, we didnt deserve this from Book 6. I mean, could you actually believe that it was really JKR who had written it when you turned the pages? Well, shit happens - you'll just have to wipe it off and smile, i guess
 

Sparkling Green Eyes
Unsigned | Chapter : 1 | Date : 29/07/05
Wow i really needed something like that- considering hermione is my favourite character in this series....i couldn't put to words the shock i had after reading that book...but thank-you for writting this story. It was truly amazing.
Author Feedback: WOW! My first reviewer after re-posting! I was afraid people wouldn't if they'd already read the first version.

Thanks a bunch!
 

<< prev
jump   |
 

Page generated in 0.00699 seconds. 177 users currently online.
Server running: Portkey Version 2, coded by James & Skinned by Imran(NAPPA).