AnonymousUnsigned | Chapter : 1 | Date : 25/03/09
hey i wish u'd continued on that story, its quite interestng this one! |
| |
I can't say I had much love for Cho... or any at at all, come to think of it. Reading this really reminded me of that!
I love different POV fics. I think that's one of the greatest disappointments (necessary, but upsetting nonetheless) is that we don't get Hermione's POV in any of the the books. She's pretty much the second most important character in the series, and you know there had to a whole slew of things going on behind those eyes. We're just left to wonder how different those events were for her, so thanks for shedding the interpretive light!
|
| |
|
Ah, poor Hermione, having to help Harry when she clearly wanted to be anywhere else. Fantastic last paragraph, by the way. A wonderful follow up to the amazing "Half an Hour". Any chance that we could ever see more from Hermione's POV? You seem to have her locked in incredibly well. Wonderfully written and finely paced. I loved her internal talks. Wonderful story! |
Author Feedback: Thank you! Well, I wish I could write some of Hermione's POV in Half Blood Prince -- if I could figure it out! I swear, the girl regressed in that book. Here's hoping she makes up for it in Book 7.
Take care, and thanks again for reviewing. |
| |
bradSigned | Chapter : 1 | Date : 28/02/07
I've read this before but never commented, I think. Just had a quick re-read of it now. Very good, but that last bit, about Cho *punishing* Harry, is excellent, very effective, I can feel Hermione's anger.
"Ginny shows upat the table at that moment, for which I'll probably owe her a wizard's debt for eternity"
Oh dear. Reading this *after* the debacle that was HBP ... *am sad for Hermione*. |
Author Feedback: Wotcher, brad. Sorry it took me so long to respond to your review -- I haven't been around as much as I'd like. Anyway, thanks for your thoughts. I do suspect that, after their disastrous date, Cho punished Harry for the rest of the book. (Even that one moment of tenderness, after the Quibbler came out, was more for public consumption than any genuine affection, methinks.)
Harry deserves better than Cho *or* Ginny. |
| |
sartoneSigned | Chapter : 1 | Date : 27/07/06
"After all my explanations that's the only thing he heard, and he heard it as a slight against me. And no one gets to insult me while he's around, not even me."
OMG! OMG! That's gotta be one of the best lines I've ever read! Great follow up to half an hour! Thanks again. |
Author Feedback: ((grin)) So glad you liked it! But it's true, isn't it? No one, not Snape, not Malfoy, no one, gets to slight Hermione while Harry's around. "Delusional" my foot. |
| |
|
This is a wonderful take in one of the most revealing scenes in OotP. Excellent! Thank you for this POV. |
Author Feedback: My pleasure. This one sort of grew from "Half an Hour", where we delved into Hermione's POV earlier in the book. I'm glad you liked it. Take care, now... |
| |
CallieUnsigned | Chapter : 1 | Date : 12/07/05
i love your storys from hermiones point of view!  its totally what shes thinking too. great job!
ps i HATE that cho chang b!tch |
Author Feedback: Now, now... let's cut Cho some slack. Her boyfriend was murdered last year, after all... and it's not her fault she's so shallow.
I'm glad you enjoyed this peek into Hermione's head. Thanks muchly for reviewing! Enjoy your weekend... I know I will. **cough**HalfBloodPrince**cough** |
| |
I never dreamed it would be torture.
Every one of Skeeter's questions reopened another bleeding wound. Every answer forced him to relive a memory from Hell. By the end of the interview I knew this would make his nightmares worse, not better. But he went through with it to the end… because he's the bravest man I've ever known.
This is a perfect description of Hermione in book 5. She is trying so hard to be helpful in every possible way, but she doesn't always think things through completely. I'm glad you have given her this insight into herself...that is how we grow.
'Tough.' That must be the guy-talk way to describe it. 'Performing a self-appendectomy with a rusty paring knife' would be more accurate.
ummm, yuck.
and then the whole discussion with him regarding the fiasco of a date with Cho...how painful. I feel the knife in the gut feeling myself. Again, I am surprised by your grasp of the nuances of teen girl angst. (I've *been* a teenage girl full of angst...you, unless I'm tremendously mistaken, have NOT!!
 )
anyway, this is a good take on Hermione's emotions at the time of the disastrous Valentine date. Perhaps when HBP comes out we'll have a little more clearance on her feelings. |
Author Feedback: Hi, CP! Thank you for reviewing again... I'm grateful, you know that don't you?
Just for the record: No, I've never been a teenage girl, angst-ridden or otherwise. But I have nieces... and if one watches, one learns.
When Hermione asked Harry to interrupt his date with Cho, I don't think Hermione at all realized what it would look like to Cho -- but it would certainly be compounded by Harry sitting with Hermione later! Small wonder Cho has the opinion of Hermione she does.
I had fun writing this story: unlike "Half an Hour", I had to work hard to make sense of Hermione's feelings and words in this scene. This was my spin on it... others' mileage may vary.
Thanks again! -- P. |
| |
|
I love this story! It was beautiful and very enjoyable to read. I hope you write more in the future! |
| |
|
I love this one, really. I like how you put Hermione's feelings. |
Author Feedback: Thanks! Hermione's feelings can be hard to write. She can be very, um, reserved in the books... except for SPEW and other such things, we don't know anything about who or what she likes (coughHarrycough). This just seemed to be a good explanation of that scene.
Take care... Paracelsus. |
| |
HikaruSigned | Chapter : 1 | Date : 26/04/05
HA! Lovely, again a nice little fic. I'm actually getting fond of this fics where authors review a scene of a book through a character's PoV, it really gives a new view to the situation. Have you considered doing one of the scene where Harry and Cho fights (you know, when he's going to meet Snape, and they start fighting about Marietta, and they end up with Hermione?). It's a very short scene, but it might turn out in something interesting.
|
Author Feedback: Hmmm, I'll have to think about it. Of course, the only other PoV for that scene would be Cho's, and somehow I don't think there's anything about Cho's mindset that wasn't made clear in OotP. Still, now that the idea's lodged in my brain, something may percolate up.
Thanks for taking the time to review, Hikaru-san. You know I appreciate it.
-- Paracelsus. |
| |
AtlanticaUnsigned | Chapter : 1 | Date : 25/04/05
You're a brilliant writer. I really like the way you give us your perspective on Hermione's feelings. Please write more soon! |
Author Feedback: Thank you very much... although I assure you, I've read some brilliant works here on Portkey, and I've a ways to go before I match up. But I do intend to write more, and that soon. And reviews like yours help!
Thanks again -- Paracelsus. |
| |
|
I really liked this story. I read half an Hour and enjoyed it and am trying to write a fanfic in Hermione's POV about something from the book. Thanks for writing it! |
Author Feedback: I look forward to reading it! Yeah, the more we get from Hermione's PoV, the better. And while I doubt I'm the first to write these scenes from the view of someone besides Harry, I feel sure I won't be the last. I love this fandom....
Anyway, thanks for reviewing my little snippet. Take care...
-- Paracelsus. |
| |
dazzleboxUnsigned | Chapter : 1 | Date : 23/04/05
That was interesting. It's an interesting twist, your conceit that Hermione is actively trying to get Harry and Cho together as opposed to my vision of her mostly trying to not interfere, and it's intriguing. I'm fascinated by the explorations of these two moments, and yours is certainly food for thought. Though I can't help feeling that your internal dialogue for Hermione is somewhat ... colder(?) than I would expect. I look forward to seeing more from you.
One point: By the time this conversation takes place, Hermione knows that Neville's parents are in the long-term ward at St. Mungo's and she knows why. Remember this takes place after Mr. Weasley has been attacked. So her "Interesting..." comments comes off badly, she knows exactly why Neville focuses on the death eaters. |
Author Feedback: Thanks for the thoughtful review. You're right, I missed the point that Hermione had seen Neville's parents when this scene took place. I still think, though, that she'd notice Neville's remark here, particularly coupled with his sudden learning spurt in the D.A. I should have said more than "Interesting," though, you're right.
I see Hermione as an odd combination of rational thought and vivid passion. She prefers to focus on the rational part of her, which is why I wrote her internal dialogue as I did. Trust me, if this were the scene in PoA where Harry'd fallen off his broom at the Quidditch match, her thoughts woudn't be nearly so coherent!
I love reviews that make me think! Thank you so much for taking a moment...
-- Paracelsus. |
| |
H_HrFanSigned | Chapter : 1 | Date : 22/04/05
Why, that vicious, conniving little…
Gotta love that Hermione! Cho is a vicious, conniving little.......
Wonderful little story from Hermione's point of view. You did a great job with it. Everything seemed to fall in to place exceedingly well!
Thanks for such a terrific version of events!
Take care,
H_HrFan |
Author Feedback: Yes, I have to agree: Cho *is* a vicious, conniving little [insert derogatory noun here]. I can't help but feel that we're going to see this in full force in the next book.
Glad you liked this take on Hermione's viewpoint. I'm especially glad it sounded authentic to you. Thanks so much for telling me!
Have a good weekend... -- Paracelsus. |
| |
|