|
Wow. I am sorry but I will not be able to read this fanfic. You have some good ideas, but you do not follow J.K. Rowling's character development at all. Fred and George whiny? Really?
Try proof-reading your stories a few times before you post too. There are a lot of mistakes, like "Exchanged student' instead of "Exchange" There is no "d" on the end, it's not in the past tense.
The process of accepting the student is full of holes too. Dumbledore would not suddenly just send a letter to a family telling them they will be supporting an exchange student. Families have to apply for that sort of thing...
Dumbledore is also supposed to be the wisest wizard of all time. He would know whether or not the school specialized in dark magic too.
Anyway, seeing how this fanfic was supposedly your first, and written a few years ago, I will take a look to see if you have others, and what they are like. I hope I will be able to read them. Good luck. |
| |
aditivatsSigned | Chapter : 1 | Date : 30/07/08
I have just started reading this story and i m simply loving it. Thumbs up for u |
| |
this has to be my ALL TIME favorite story on Portkey! i had actually read this about 2 years ago, but at that time i didn't have an account, so i'm reviewing now, 2 years later. but seriously, i absolutely LOVE this story  it's hilarious, i personally don't like all new stories 'cuz they're all really serious and having to do with the last book, so i love this one, awesome job! |
| |
manitildeSigned | Chapter : 4 | Date : 28/10/07
uh, what the heck is up with Snape? that's just ...odd. |
| |
AnonymousUnsigned | Chapter : 1 | Date : 09/09/07
definite hints of a relation to harry here! red hair, dead parents. hope im right, tho an OC/harry fic wouldnt go amiss |
| |
AnonymousUnsigned | Chapter : 36 | Date : 18/07/07
the story line had it\'s ups and it\'s downs, but all in all, ithink I really liked it and i can\'t wait to read angel kiss and don\'t forget to floss. i expect they should be awsome too.one confusing thing: aren\'t neville\'s parents dead? |
| |
AnonymousUnsigned | Chapter : 1 | Date : 12/06/07
Z0mg u sux H/HG is gh3y! Y0u suX balls bitch!
U sux b4lls!!!!  |
| |
AnonymousUnsigned | Chapter : 2 | Date : 28/04/07
Yep, definetly Harry's sister. She looked like lilly didn't she when mrs weasley didn't finish the sentence? |
| |
|
Is she like harry's sister or something?? They both had thier parents die in england at a young age. It could be? |
| |
AnonymousUnsigned | Chapter : 4 | Date : 19/04/07
I was amused/horrified by Snape's apron. I must admit I'm rather intrigued, but everyone was incredibly OOC. Are they supposed to be? |
| |
AnonymousUnsigned | Chapter : 5 | Date : 16/03/07
Ok, i had to write something before i went mad. I only got to chapter four but i could not continue. There are so many problems with your story. The charactors are just too ooc. Snape in an apron singing??? Mouldyshorts twirling and planning a dance?!?!?! Hagrid suddenly aging over 2 years?! Dumbledoor feeble?? Harry's letter and hermiones airheadedness. it is just all so so wrong. They all speak as if they are american when they are supposed to be british.. Dumbledoor would have sorted nellie with the hat, as with any new student. They need to tell which house she goes in by her charactoristics, not which table has empty seats - they can use magic to extend the table! I'm sure there are many,many others who would like to read your story but for me its just too Out of charactor and unbelievable. |
| |
|
i love your story.how you made ron a werewolf and how he found leila and they fell in love it's really sweet! |
| |
|
Really good story i really love it. no i adore it. can't wait for more |
| |
Hermione: Theres something i have to tell you.
Harry: What ?
Harry: Theres something i have to tell you too...
Hermione: What you first.
Harry: i think
Harry: im falling in love with..
Harry: you.
Hermione: me ?
Hermione: oh well thats good
Harry: it is ?
Hermione: yes i think ive fell in love with you...
Harry:
Hermione: I  you
Harry:  But you  ron and i  ginny.
Hermione: But u said u  me !
Harry: i do i just need time to fink .
Hermione: ok thats fine... i'm going to see ron and tell him its over and i hate him...
Harry: me to
Hermione:  U  RON TOO ??
harry: NO 'laughs' i love you !
Hermione:  bye x |
| |
MikeeUnsigned | Chapter : 36 | Date : 25/05/06
Amazing! This is my first time to read this kind of Fanfiction.. |
| |
|