LOGIN PANEL :

Displaying Reviews for
Unrequited

Total Reviews: 47

View chapters for a specific chapter:

jump   | next >>
addisonj
Signed | Chapter : 1 | Date : 19/10/09
Just lovely. Leaves an ache and a sigh. So many other H/Hr fics I've been reading have H liking Hr first and keeping his tongue until she figures out a year or two later; interesting to see this spin on it. Since I personally relate more to Hr than H (bookish vs sporty and the Chosen One), all the sadder!
Author Feedback: Hey Addison-

I see you've moved along to another one. Thanks. And I'm glad you liked it. I've always been the bookish sort myself, and so empathize with Hermione more than Harry too. Besides, sometimes Harry is just so thick. And he can behave like such a DUDE. Because he is a dude, but still.

Anyway, thanks again.

-Ahn Na Blue
 

atiqah
Signed | Chapter : 1 | Date : 04/07/09
They were right. This is beautiful. This is a tear-filled story. It touched me in every emotional way possible.
 

Malowane
Unsigned | Chapter : 1 | Date : 30/05/09
Very good one shot. I have tears in my eyes. ^^ It was quite intense. It feels so true... I mean, what Hermione feels at this right moment, looking at Harry... I wish JKR realized what was before her eyes!
 

gal-texter
Signed | Chapter : 1 | Date : 30/11/08
Why did JKR have to ruin our fun with that dumb epilogue. Pointless. Vindictive. Woman.

Hee, PK-ers have been talking here about JKR saying that H/H could've happened.

Man, I love to make people weep. Is that wrong?


LOL.

 

Fire_
Signed | Chapter : 1 | Date : 29/11/08
Aww thank you for that absolutely lovely respose! I never even thought that I would get a reply since this story was published in '04 but I did and it u was one of the sweetest and nicest ones!

A LOT of people absolutely adored this one-shot you might want to check this thread out: http://talk.portkey.org/index.php?s=&showtopic=31294&view=findpost&p=316614

I agree with everything you said about H/Hr, she was always there right there, and yet it still amazes me how JKR could deny this pairing their justified ending, and you know what shocks me even more she KNEW H/Hr had something. Have you hear the new quote where JKR admitted that H/Hr could have easily happened?

Once again thank you for that really sweet reply, made me feel warm and fuzzy and I absoltuley MUST read your other fics if this is any indication to your brilliance because honest to god you captured it so well. The events of the book and through Hermione's eyes it was truly beautiful and so RIGHT the way you wrote it. Absolutely brilliant job! And like I said on the forum this fic is actually one of the most poigant and touchign H/Hr one shots I have read! Absoltuely favourited!

xoxo
Hana
 

Fire_
Signed | Chapter : 1 | Date : 29/11/08
*sniff* OMG hold on I need to regain any semblance for speech.

Ok I think I *may* have recovered though the shaky feeling in my hands as I type this is telling me the exact opposite thing. This was one of the most poigant, heart-breaking, beautiful fics I have read about H/Hr. The emotion in this story combined with the uncanny exactness of Hermione's voice, it absolutely killed me, but in this absolutely beautiful way.

" In a perfect world, he would lie upon the bed with me so that I might hold him. He would tell me everything instead of bottling it away. He would smile. He would laugh. He would have healthy parents, and I would be in here because of a charms accident instead of a nearly successful killing curse.

But this isn’t that world. In this world he has to stand strong for everyone, stand alone, and all I can do is what I’ve always done. Help him. Stand behind him. Be there with my silly books and cleverness whenever he needs me. "

"One day, Harry Potter. One day you’ll turn around and really see me."

One of the most heart-touching, heart-felt, heart-breaking lines I have ever read. Truly beautiful. It absolutely connected with my heart and actually left me speechless.

You combine the bitter truth of their existence, with Hermione's pure and innocent but absolutely earth shatteringly strong love and convey that they're so young, oh so young, her selflessness and then Harry's pain, and so simply you show their love, it's absoltuely brilliant! Absolutely AMAZING story!

xoxo
Hana
Author Feedback: Hana-

Best. Review. Ever.

Or at least certainly one of the best. I love this particularly short and sad piece, so I'm glad that it did what I thought it did...which was to be short and sad, yet fairly authentic. Thanks for catching all the canon stuff, and it's good to know I nailed Hermione's voice pretty well. And also, thanks for quoting. I love it when readers quote their favorite parts. Makes me feel so fuzzy and warm.

How could JKR not see how devoted Hermione was? And to who. Silly, silly woman. It's too bad that Harry never did turn around and see the girl who'd been there all along.

Thanks for reading!

-Ahn Na
 

gal-texter
Signed | Chapter : 1 | Date : 21/11/08
*puts on reader's hat*

Oh man, that was beautiful! Fantastic! I've seen this linked in Accio Harry's forum sig for a while now, but I've been avoiding it due to her tissue warning (her sig labels this as "The H/H one shot that always leaves me in tears"). But the angst here was just at the right level.

You also did a very good of incorporating canon references. From her dentist dad to Cho and Viktor noticing H/H's bond to Hermione's use of the Time Turner.

This are the Harry and Hermione we know from Books 1-5. She always puts his well-being above hers. She realized her feelings for him before he could do the same for her. Her analytical mind understands that he's slow to feel love, but that someday he'll really her.

OTOH, he feels terribly guilty that he had put his friends in danger. He's oblivious that she's falling in love with him.

Now there, I think this review's 1/10 the length of your fic. Hahaha! I wouldn't know if you still come here to read your reviews, or if you get them by email. But nonetheless, thanks for sharing this story.

Author Feedback: Gal Texter-

Hey, thanks for reading, and rec-ing, and doing all this cool stuff like noticing my canon references. I swear, Portkey was always the best place to learn about all things Potter, and if ever a fic writer messes up on something canon, the flaming reviews start pouring in. How I miss those days when the debates raged on. Why did JKR have to ruin our fun with that dumb epilogue. Pointless. Vindictive. Woman.

Anyway, thanks again. I don't often come in here to leave replies, maybe once every few months, but your review was quite nice, so I wanted to pop in here ASAP.

I should probably pass along a thanks to Accio Harry for the tissue warning. Man, I love to make people weep. Is that wrong?

-Ahn Na Blue
 

gal-texter
Signed | Chapter : 1 | Date : 21/11/08
Hi there.

I used my prerogative as Fic Recs Mod to enter this into the fic rec-engine here. From my years of mod-ing Portkey, I know that there too often, PK-ers don't make recs themselves for various reasons. E.g. too lazy or forgot to or couldn't understand how the rec-engine works, etc.)

I don't suppose you've posted this story anywhere else? I googled for it but didn't find any alternative places where we could find it. But in case you have, feel free to post alternate URLs and anything else civil in the rec data's Link to Discussion Forum.
 

mlui
Signed | Chapter : 1 | Date : 20/08/08
Good luck to Hermione! This is a very nice, albeit short, story. =)
 

Anonymous
Unsigned | Chapter : 1 | Date : 16/04/08
This is so well written. It flows so well. I started CRYING...and I don't do that often!
 

Malinda/AccioHarry!
Unsigned | Chapter : 1 | Date : 19/03/08
Okay, so this has been my fav. one-shot for quite some time (I even have it linked in my PK siggy so others can enjoy it). Anyhoo, it inspired me to make a vid:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kbPIJCKL4HY

I hope you\\\'ll check it out. Also, would you mind if I linked the story in the video description? That way, you could get some credit and people could read your story and see my inspiration

- Malinda
Author Feedback: Wow Malinda. Great video. And I love that song. Thanks for reminding me to get it on my iPod.

It's been a long time since I've been lured back here to reply to any reviews, but of course I had to tell you how much I enjoyed the vid. I haven't seen the order of the phoenix movie yet ( and truthfully I wasn't keen to) but those clips of yours almost make me change my mind. And I suppose I should...I do own the DVD, after all.

Awesome. And link my story whereever you want. I'm so flattered that you liked it.

Thanks for reading!
Ahn Na
 

papermask
Signed | Chapter : 1 | Date : 15/03/08
SO SAD. Seriously, this is really sad. But very pwerful. Maybe one dya you'll continue it?
 

GuardianMedic
Signed | Chapter : 1 | Date : 29/12/07
Hey Harry?
Even with those glasses... You are still completely blind!!!


Sorry, just wanted to add that.
 

GuardianMedic
Signed | Chapter : 1 | Date : 27/12/07
Oh god how I wish that had happened...
Instead we got the crapilogue...

I loved this story.
Very well done
 

britti
Signed | Chapter : 1 | Date : 13/07/07
you are a great writer.i really enjoyed this story & i look forward to reading your other stories
 

jump   | next >>
 

Page generated in 0.0117 seconds. 183 users currently online.
Server running: Portkey Version 2, coded by James & Skinned by Imran(NAPPA).