ok while i found the story interesting it wasnt very a good plot it sounded alot like it was rushed and ooc for hermiones part. iv read alot, and i mean alot, of these stories where harry and hermione go and eat pumpkin pie in the kitchen and have a whipped cream fight and end up kissing on the ground.maybe its just me but these one-shots where it is completely unblieveable just is a waste of time. while ur was not a waste of time at all be alittle more creative in ur plot and think of something alittle more original! iv read some of ur other stories and have to say i love them! hope im not being to harse keep em' coming!

i thourght that it was splended brought a big smile to my face and a cupple of tears

It just isn't working for me. Thanksgiving is strictly a American Holiday, although it is celebrated in Canada in October. I personally am American, but mixing a Holiday, based on peole leaving a country for a better life, and celebrating that Holiday in that country left, it hust doesn't work. Did that make any sense, or am I just typing in very random stuff? I'm not much of a literary scholar.

thanks for the great holiday story. i'm thankful for jk and all the great fanfiction authors. this story completed my night.

Thanksgiving? In England? Isn't that americanising the books a little too much? I can accept minor things (such as differences in slang) but having English characters celebrate a wholly American holiday which most would've only heard of though American movies and TV shows, if at all, is a bit much don't you think? Sure I may be going overboard (after all it's just a bit of fun right?) but please!

though you mixed the culures it's ok...

my history teacher onced said that...the Brits, Americans and the people Down Under are all cousins and they came from one race...so I guess it's ok...

and besides this is the Magical World we are talking about...Nothing is Impossible except coming to life again, that is...

i really like it...it's a sweet little story...

you're very good...

Oh, what a sweet little story! I loved it! Just short and sweet from start to finish!

great one shot. just what we all needed on thanksgiving. a little bit o' fluff!! it was very cute. great job.

well techincally since it is Thanksgiving, a tradition formally made a holiday in the 1860s by Abraham Lincoln celebrating the first year in the Colonies (away from Britian), it is an American Tradition...but I liked this anyway! It was very creative and yay it hinted Draco/Ginny too!!! But I liked how Harry was thankful for hermione, and who doesn't like a whip cream fight? *wink*

THANKSGIVING IS AN ***AMERICAN*** HOLIDAY!!!! Why the heck would some Brits be celebrating a holiday instituted by a group of their people who gave them the finger, took a ship to America, and later kicked their asses in a war? IT MAKES NO SENSE!!!!! You can't just slap a foreign holiday on another culture to fit your plot. People who think the rest of the world operates exactly like their own country or *should* are what's wrong with it. Either you don't actually know the history of Thanksgiving or you don't care. I'm not sure which makes me more sad.

But... they're... British. They don't celebrate Thanksgiving. It's strictly an American holiday the last time I checked. But hey, the plot was nice.

That was great and funny keep up the great work.Thank you for all that has whent in to this story.

LoL. Sorry. Saw this from the front page, so I didn't read the description. Good to know that you know it's not really celebrated, haha. But like I said, great story anyway!

This is a great fic. Just thought that I'd point out, though, that they obviously wouldn't celebrate Thanksgiving in England...

Very wonderful.... one thing though.... Do the Brits even have thanksgiving??? Just wondering take no offence by my question. In others words i think it was a lovely fic.