AnonymousUnsigned | Chapter : 1 | Date : 28/07/07
wow! what a great fan fic! I really like the fact that Harry was rejected.. but it\'s so sad.. |
| |
AnonymousUnsigned | Chapter : 1 | Date : 24/04/07
THEY KILLED THEMSELVES??!
good story but rather depressing...
good job anyway! |
| |
AnonymousUnsigned | Chapter : 1 | Date : 30/09/05
its so sad but good i also love this song have you seen the music video its sweet well i read your you raise me up fic too and i also love that song it was great |
| |
too~realUnsigned | Chapter : 1 | Date : 11/08/05
this story was a little depressing, dont you think? I liked it but it was really sad, suicide, i mean thats something that happens in real life. I like to read fanfictions bc they take you away from real life. But this fic reminded me of to much of real life bc this week i went to a funeral where the woman did the same thing. I like fics where it takes you out of the real world a little bit. Harry killing himself, i cant think about that. |
| |
|
omgosh me and my friend are major h/hr believers and when we read this we like cried (i almost always cry with the song too) i hope nothing like that (harry and hermione dying i mean). great short story though. |
| |
It's so sad!  Why must the good die young? Why, why, why????? ...... Oh well. Can your next stories be a little more happy and a little less suicidal? |
| |
kaylynUnsigned | Chapter : 1 | Date : 09/06/05
|
| |
|
I didn't particularly care for this story, mostly because of the timeline involved. The way the story reads, all of this happens within 4 or 5 days, whereas the events in the song take place over several years, w/the characters slowly wasting away. This story basically says: Monday Harry has heart broken drinks himself to death and is found by Hermione, Thurs/Friday Harry's buried, Hermione starts drinking, Ginny stops by, Ginny leaves, Hermione drinks herself to death. It just doesn't seem fully developed to me. |
| |
|
I thought it was ok but are you going to make a sequel? |
| |
tashaSigned | Chapter : 1 | Date : 13/03/05
sad sad story...i think that is one of the sadest ones i have ever read...really good though |
| |
|
I'm sorry, I enjoyed your writing and love that song, but I'm tired of depressing fan fiction. Especially when it's about two characters near to my heart. I also couldn't believe that Harry would just give up it's not like him. He would fight for her no matter what. Sorry that it had to be the review to you fanfic but all the depressing fanfiction is starting to depress me. |
| |
HarrieSigned | Chapter : 1 | Date : 23/01/05
i have this song on my computer, in fact im listening to it right now while i read this. this is a accually the second fiction based on this song ive found. both are well done |
| |
lissaSigned | Chapter : 1 | Date : 30/12/04
Really great/sad story you have here. I've only heard that song once, but I loved it and the story you wrote went with it so well. Great job. |
| |
Well you killed off my favourite charaters but the story was good. what i believe in is that love can make you do crazy things. in this case it was suicide and trying to drink a memory away. poor hermione, but she's with harry now. that's good right? if this does not make sense don't blame me. i'm only in grade 5 and almost no one can uderstand me! KEEP UP THE GOOD WORK! |
| |
HarrysgrlSigned | Chapter : 1 | Date : 11/10/04
that was a little depressing, but hey, life cant all be good now can it? but other wise good job. |
| |
|