Oh my gosh. This story is simply beautiful!!! The whole time reading it I had a smile on my face. All of your works are brilliant. I think you do a fantastic job of keeping Harry and Hermione in character. Simply marvelous

It was well written, but just too darn sad. You caught me.....I NEVER read anything where Harry dies. I couldn't even stand Hedwig dying!

Utterly beautiful. I was quite shocked to know Harry had died, but it was well done. A very sweet story, I must say. I love how you portrayed Harry. Aces!

By far one of my absolute favorite stories!!!
I LOVE this one... So happy to have re-read it once again... I truly miss the pre HBP days... Thank you Charm, you're an amazing author.

I have read this only now, as I am combing through fanfic to keep my heart light after HBP. And, I must say I loved it so much.

Thanks for writing and sharing this!

That was really beautiful, bittersweet and sad! Wonderfully written...I even got a little teary.

Very well written.

I do not like stories where either Harry or Hermione dies. In general, I want to have happy endings to my fan fics. There's too much heartaches in real life. I could do without my hero/heroine dying in fiction.

Still, you write well.

Amazing. Brilliant. This was a wonderful letter, though it seems to contradict your pseudonym slightly. Wonderful story, filled with profound meanings.

You know this is probably one of my favorite stories and let me tell you I have read a lot of stories. But this is probably one of the few that actually made me cry. It truly was bittersweet.

i ... i am speechless .... i think that this is probably eiter or bothe my favorite and your best fic so far.... but as i havent reached the last 3 in your profile than that opinion might change..... i love how you did it in a letter to her .. son... and well yeah the only thing i dont like is harry dieing but i can live w/ that as he probably will die in the end.... anywho... good work keep it up and thanks for providing things for a boring (and sometimes bored but never when reading fics) HP fan to read....
Hannah X.
Hp_band_nerd2@yahoo.com

Man, I loved it. It would be perfect to the story plot.

Wow...that was just....wow. Truly and completely amazing. This is one of the VERY few fics I've ever read that almost made me cry (and trust me, I don't cry at anything). It was so..wow..I can't even put it into words. You are a truly talented writer.

That "sob" was so "sob" sad!!! more more!!!! maybe something about Harry and Hermione's son???? I hate to say this but maybe Harry dying made the story better o my god I have to go and pretend I didnt say that!!! Keep writing I think if JK next book is the same as the fifth I die of depression and Ill die thiking you are a better writer than her I think you almost as good now

This was beautiful CC, even with the death of Harry. It was truly bittersweet.

Oh. My. God. You killed Harry.
I just hope to God JKR doesn't do the same!
Still, brilliantly written. Damn - dead Harry.
xxxx Lady Jane xxxx