LOGIN PANEL :

Displaying Reviews for
It's The Great Pumpkin, Harry Potter!

Total Reviews: 47

View chapters for a specific chapter:

<< prev
jump   | next >>
Potter's Hermione
Signed | Chapter : 1 | Date : 24/09/04
awwwwwww~ the perspective that u chose was very nice! n the twist that u added was very very very funny. It made me laugh out loud but somewhat gross if u think about it~
 

eizzaj
Unsigned | Chapter : 7 | Date : 17/08/04
I loved your great pumpkin story, it was awesome thanks for posting it.
 

Shocky
Unsigned | Chapter : 1 | Date : 29/06/04
Expertly written, Romulus, very enjoyable, with a satisfying element of obscurity.

Congratulations on creating such an interesting Fic.
 

Miss_Mione
Signed | Chapter : 7 | Date : 28/06/04
Wow, this is no nothing. I actually think this could win a prize. It's magnificent. Beyond words might I say. If you were able to write something like this when you had only just started writing, I believe you're not just someone. I think you should seriously consider writing more than just fanfic. I hope to read more of your hand soon, as I think you're among the best authors here on Portkey, and elsewhere. You're the best, keep going.
Author Feedback:

Thank you.

Such an inadequate way to express my gratitude for a review which is truly, truly touching. And, truth to tell, I'm crying as I read this.

May I also say 'thank you' for nominating this fic for the Portkey Readers Choice Awards? I seldom drop by there (mainly because of a heartless and evil RL situation), but someone told me that you'd posted a nomination for this fic ... and I nearly fell off my chair when I saw the nomination.

I'm not sure if the nomination will get in, however. If I remember the rules correctly, the fics should have been completed before the nomination period is opened (of course, I may be wrong, in which case I hope Joyce and Pat do consider this in the final cut.)

In any case, being nominated there is already an honor in and of itself, and I owe that to you.

(Right now, I'm tempted to go looking for the badge that the Gred and Forge Weasley gave to Percy in PoA: "Big Head Boy."

I guess the reason I'm feeling more than giddy right now is because, as I said in my author's notes, I never really thought of this fic as being on par or of the quality that so many other fics in portkey have. I remember writing it as some sort of a lark (in a way, an effort to get away from the major angst attacks I was having when writing 'Epiphanies' at the same time as this and other stories). I had always thought that this fic was too juvenile in a way, too sophomoric and (again) not really of the quality that other great and wonderful H/Hr writers have in their own works.

Which was why I never really did think of posting this to portkey.

But now, with reviews such as yours ... I am truly humbled.

And eternally grateful.

Thank you so very very much.

gil
 

KypDurron
Signed | Chapter : 7 | Date : 28/06/04
LMAO!!! The. Best. Prank. Ever.

Top that, Weasley Twins.

I wonder who pulled it off though.

Remus, maybe? With some help from beyond the veil?
 

KypDurron
Signed | Chapter : 6 | Date : 28/06/04
Finally! The admission of Wheeeeeeeeeee!

Hmmm, methinks the unknown persons are Ginny and the Terrible Two.
 

KypDurron
Signed | Chapter : 5 | Date : 28/06/04
Constant vigilance, Gryffindors. Constant vigilance.

Hoo boy, if Gred and Forge are the Junior Marauders, then what does that make Ca and Cindy?
 

KypDurron
Signed | Chapter : 4 | Date : 28/06/04
Wise words from the floating vegetable/fruit thing.

Eep! All those reminders of the past.
 

KypDurron
Signed | Chapter : 3 | Date : 28/06/04
Whoa. Five pumpkins floating up from the pumpkin patch and heading towards Hogwarts? What do they want? Are their intentions for good or for evil?
 

MissLexiRe
Unsigned | Chapter : 7 | Date : 28/06/04
Uncle Remus - that explains the Snape pumpkin! Now, did Dumbledore do it? I guess we will never know. *grin* Great story.
 

gerdieSI
Signed | Chapter : 7 | Date : 28/06/04
That was the best story...how could you not want to post it. I loved the prank, it was the best, topped anything Fred and George ever did. The scene with Harry and Hermione is one of the most beautiful I have ever read. I loved the scene b/w the four of them and how Ginny and Ron finally thanked Harry for all he had done and made him listen!
 

MissLexiRe
Unsigned | Chapter : 6 | Date : 28/06/04
Wow - that was fantastic! Completion is such a great description of what we imagine true love to be. Wow. Now where are the other three pumpkins?
 

MissLexiRe
Unsigned | Chapter : 5 | Date : 28/06/04
Our little Weasleys are growing up! I'm so proud! What a great chapter.
 

KypDurron
Signed | Chapter : 2 | Date : 28/06/04
Awww. A trip down memory lane.

LMAO! What in the name of Merlin does Malfoy think he's doing?
 

MissLexiRe
Unsigned | Chapter : 4 | Date : 28/06/04
What a great message and such an interesting way to pass it on! Great chapter.
 

<< prev
jump   | next >>
 

Page generated in 0.00722 seconds. 226 users currently online.
Server running: Portkey Version 2, coded by James & Skinned by Imran(NAPPA).