smhalcyonSigned | Chapter : 25 | Date : 26/07/08
I enjoyed the extended epilogue. A lot of authors finish the scene of Voldemorts death and then give a long chapter that only gives highlights. |
| |
smhalcyonSigned | Chapter : 16 | Date : 26/07/08
awesome chapter. I liked the battle sequence. I particularily enjoyed that Voldemort had to alter Ron and Draco to be mages because they were to weak otherwise. |
| |
smhalcyonSigned | Chapter : 13 | Date : 26/07/08
Nice. I like it. I was wondering where the Jedi part in the title came from. So is Lucas a squib or an un-Oblivated muggle that saw some mages duke it out and turned it into Star Wars? I was happy to finally see the two togehter. I also just realized the story summary and my guess is Ron is a mage being trained by the sorcerer. Though, Ron having enough power to be a mage seems far-fetched. |
| |
smhalcyonSigned | Chapter : 11 | Date : 26/07/08
Nice so far. Ron is a mystery and I am intriged what is happening with him. Harry is defenitely thick when it comes to girls and feelings associated with them. |
| |
smhalcyonSigned | Chapter : 6 | Date : 26/07/08
Nice chapter. I am predicting that Ron is be revruited to be a Death Eater unknowingly at the moment. |
| |
smhalcyonSigned | Chapter : 4 | Date : 26/07/08
Nice chapters up to this point. I think the decission to hide Hermione's power from Harry will bite Albus in the butt. |
| |
smhalcyonSigned | Chapter : 1 | Date : 26/07/08
An interesting start. I have enjoyed some of your other work and checking out your older stuff. |
| |
mione713Signed | Chapter : 1 | Date : 22/01/08
Please update this story as I love to read this one. |
Author Feedback: Er...it is completed... |
| |
AnonymousUnsigned | Chapter : 14 | Date : 13/12/07
I liked the way Harry and Hermione were completely oblivious - which was portrayed by their inner doubts on numerous passages.
I dislike the pace you are setting, too fast with no attention to detail. Sure enough, that may be intentional but you can accomplish that with just a few more descriptive paragraphs.
On that note, the excessive use of the punctuation "..." denotes reticence, an unwillingness to share more information. Again perhaps this is intentional, but makes for a fregmented story - I am a firm believer of the leeway you must create so the reader can immerse in the story and imagine the scenes left unsaid.
However, I do believe they are being overused.
Save for these remarks, it's a nice story, congratulations on writing it. |
Author Feedback: Thanks for the suggestion, although with this being the first pic I ever posted here, I like to think I've improved a bit since then. Especially on the punctuation part, while the pace...well, it's a continuous fight, I try to detail things more but it just comes out fast paced  However I'm told I've improved on that too, I hope it's true... |
| |
WELL I AM HAPPY FOR HARRY AND HERMIONE  .BUT THE STORY WAS TOO DIRECT. YOU WROTE 2 YEARS INCLUDING SUMMER HOLIDAYS AND CHRISTMAS HOLIDAYS IN 25 CHAPTERS. BUT SINCE ITS YOUR FIRST FANFIC YOU DID REALLY WELL.  .KEEP UP THE GOOD WORK. |
Author Feedback: Yeah, yeah, I know. Too rushed, isn't it?  Luckily I got better in my latest stories...or at least I hope! |
| |
brittiSigned | Chapter : 1 | Date : 07/05/07
i am looking forward to reading these chapters...i promise i will review again about how it turns out |
| |
luv4booksUnsigned | Chapter : 25 | Date : 28/05/06
|
Author Feedback: Well, ron's so easy to use as a villain, don't you think?  But if you've read all my stories, and i know you have, you've seen it's no0t always him the bad guy in my fics. It was just a phase I had in my first stories in which i totally hated him... |
| |
|
great story! the writing was a little... hmm it was like This. This. this. didnt flow as well. but seeing as this is your first peice, and since i have read some of your newer work, i can easily say that you have improved GREATLY!
the story idea was great and it was still a great read!
Maybe in the future you will go over it and make it read smoother? well thats up to you. anyways keep up the great work!
Luke |
Author Feedback: One of my first attempt, so I guess you're right. It didn't have a great flow... |
| |
AnonymousUnsigned | Chapter : 25 | Date : 01/03/06
Great fan-fic and I would look forward to another one of the same. |
Author Feedback: Thanks, but no, a sequel is not planned for this one. |
| |
|
he feewk fdsfhsdjkf sajkhf sdfk sdjfh dhskl fdsjkf hdjkf sdh VG story djhjdsahfjsdakf fjdskfb fhd jsfh askdfh adhfjk adfajkdfjadf hfkj a Sequal? dasjbfjasbfjaksdfjabfdjkadsakbfdkasf ndansdb fasdn fsd sadnf sdn amfsda fs afsasjbdf;af; f;bfasf, ;pfb ji erhtjbnfvuhrgbfhdjncv bcxuif bdasjnfbcdhsjknbc kxijzvhbnds jiaxkbfcnjaskdfbcm nxkzfhncdjskmfncjdk mndkfmn jdfk jf f jjdsjkf jsdfh asjkdfh ajdfh jh dsa HYPER EWFfasdghgfjashgfjksdafkjsadjkf SEQUAL? dafasdkhfkhasdkjfskjdafkjafkfjhdsahfjskafhjksa VERY GOOD STORY |
| |
|