Oh my God, this is, and I'm not just saying this, the BEST fanfic I've evr read. I LOVE THIS! The characters aren't one dimensional and it has a good plot and I'm on the edge of my seat. I just wanted to say, WOW!

this was too much for me, im sensitive, and i must admit i was crying half the time i was readin this. i still hate the sirius james and lily triangle. its too painful to think about how bad all of them had it, especially sirius. and i must still maintain that I dont think they would have ever liked each other that way, or at least thats what im hoping. i also hope jk rowling will write the prequel to harry potter, it would be awesome to know what really did happen.

i like the way the story is written a lot, and i love James and Lily fics, but I cant stand to think about lily and sirius being in love. it just hurts me considering how all things end up, it wouldnt be fair to either of them and i like to think that they all had separate love affairs. good work though, i like it very much.

Didn't he realize he was making love to one already dead?
Is that a line from a song somewhere? I recognize it somehow.
Lucius is a malevolent little ...

It's wreaking. And I really do not get this chapter name!
Remus is so sweet and understanding.
Lily is caught between James and Sirius, interesting perspective.

HOW COULD YOU KILL OFF SPIKE HE RULED!!! but then there was a happy ending and that made it kinda better i suppose. Great story!! kept me on the edge of my seat the whole way through but that was absolutly disgustin hearing about spike yelling underground!

This was brilliant. I loved the end, and I thought that your writing was unusually fluent for a non professional author.

Congratulations on a story well told!

I really enjoyed reading this story, I especially liked the fact that you wrote in a mature tone...it was great to see the Lupin/Calista subplot...you could have def. taken that a little more further, if you wanted to...it was really interesting. I'm a huge Sirius fan, so it was a little heartbreaking to see him so depressed...great fic! A little sad that its finished...

YOU BITCH HOW CAN YOU MAKE THIS IN TO A SIRIUS AND LILY FICTION?!! IT IS JAMES AND LILY FOREVER, IF JK ROWLING WANTED LILY AND SIRIUS TO BE TOGETHER THEN SHE WOULD HAV SAID SOMETHING, BUT IN CASE YOU HADN'T NOTICED SHE DIDN'T URGH YOU PEPLE ANNOY ME SO MUCH SOMETIMES

I read this fick awhile ago and loved it,and now I read it again and loved it even more!Great writing!I love it!I'm starting ''Return of the Shadow''right now!bye!

"""Remus raised his head to the sky and let out an earth-shattering howl. Peter was trapped with a 9 foot tall, hungry, pissed off werewolf.""

I LOVE THAT!! OMG!! It made me laugh. lol. This is such a good story, even though with all the..umm..gross parts, it is good. I just can't believe what happened between Lily, James, and Sirius and what Malfoy is doing to Lily. KEEP IT UP!!

You made me cry!!Is 2:30 in the morning and I'm crying(and i dont usually cry!!!..not cool).This is an AMAZING story!! Its beautiful but sad, depressing but funny!! It has it all! I love the way you took some chapters to just show the characters having fun for a change,you dont see that very much in the HP original books.I was kinda hoping things worked out between Calista and Remus,I didnt really see her as twisted as she really is,but oh well..Only thing I didnt like though..why oh why did you kill Spike so cruelly?!?!why did you killed him at all?!?! I loved spike!!

I just finished reading one of my favorites stories for the first time. Guess which one it was? If you didn't guess The Sacrifice, you guessed wrong.

There are so many things I want to say about this, but I can't get my thoughts in order. What I will say, is that I think this was fantastic. It flowed so well, and was so sad and funny. I loved the Sirius/Lily and the Remus/Calista. I feel so sad for everyone. I haven't read Return of the Shadow yet, but I'm on my way there. I just wanted to let you know that I absolutely loved this story.

The ending is so sad! The whole Sirius dieing thing the OotP made me sad and reading it here made me sad too!!! But this was awsome though! The whole James/Lily/Sirius love-triangle was cool. I never thought Sirius would fall for Lily or even someone else to think about it. If anything Remus/Lily, but Sirius/Lily was very nice!

Okay, I just finished reading your entire fic and I have to say that I really enjoyed it. It was really depressing but you're a really good writer and I loved it. I will read the sequel a little later!!!
-Alicia