LOGIN PANEL :

Displaying Reviews for
The Truth about Magic and Muggles

Total Reviews: 43

View chapters for a specific chapter:

jump   | next >>
Tempest
Signed | Chapter : 1 | Date : 16/09/07
This is very interesting. Please continue to update, I'm really starting to enjoy this fic.
 

Anonymous
Unsigned | Chapter : 3 | Date : 20/07/06
its great please please keep updating and writting such wonderful stories! just please don't put any ginny?harry in there!
 

MooMooAshley
Signed | Chapter : 3 | Date : 16/06/04
what dose dean rhomas have to yell at harry for! I can't believe hermionie didn't belive that... then again she could be hiding her fears and crying on the inside!
 

Bloody Sakura
Signed | Chapter : 3 | Date : 29/04/04
I really liked this. I'm brazilian too, and I had never read anything from another brazilian. Your writing and grammar skills are superb. I really hope you update this soon, because the story really got me hooked. Keep it up. ^_^
 

gal-texter
Unsigned | Chapter : 1 | Date : 26/02/04
This story is one of the first 3 NEW recs entered in our ongoing Fic Recs Engine project.

http://talk.portkey.org/index.php?showtopic=6438

And I know I'm probably talking nonsense to you at the moment.
 

gal-texter
Unsigned | Chapter : 1 | Date : 26/02/04
This story is one of the first 3 NEW recs entered in our ongoing Fic Recs Engine project.

http://talk.portkey.org/index.php?showtopic=6438

And I know I'm probably talking nonsense to you at the moment.
 

gal-texter
Signed | Chapter : 3 | Date : 21/02/04
Oh, so they'll soon be in Hogwarts! What is this suspense with Dean's note? Was he attacked or something?

I must say, I haven't quite visualized how Harry would tell his friends about the prophecy. Your take has Ron acting in character. It's quite plausible for Hermione to use logic in evaluating the prophecy.

As for Trelawney's old prophecy of Voldie's faithful servant? I gotta admit, I've always presumed she was referring to Wormtail.

The "birth and death parchment" is an interesting concept. That was a good explanation too as to why the MoM didn't publicize Sirius' death. Or maybe you plan to have Sirius back later on? Don't tell me if you do.

I chuckled at Harry noticing how Ginny has grown. Good to know he acts like a normal teenager at times, especially when it comes to noticing girls.

>>Remus: ...if you showed him how to use it, Nymphadora
Tonks: And I forbid you AGAIN to call me by that hideous name
=>Heehee!

My con crits for this chapter would be about its length and dialogue. I find it rather long. Or maybe it's just my slight headache?

Some of the teenagers spoke very formal English. Example:
Some dialogue sounded too formal for teenagers, though. Examples:
Ron: "I'd love to be able to perform magic outside Hogwarts."
=>This could be restated as "Wouldn't it be fab (or cool) to do magic outside Hogwarts?"


Ron: "Besides that, the Weasleys' Wizard Wheezes is going really well. Our household income has increased a lot with the twins' business. ..."
=>"Weasleys' Wizard Wheezes" is quite a tongue twister. It would have been more natural for Ron (or most people) to refer to it as simply, "the Twins' business", "3W", or "Fred & George's business".
The "household income" bit also sounded too formal.

Just my 0.02,
Pen
 

MGranger
Signed | Chapter : 3 | Date : 09/02/04
I think it is great, just Great! i am verry curious to know what the howler s all about!!maby gnny roke it of with him??? we'll have to wait hopefully not verry long!! great work!
 

harryherm84
Signed | Chapter : 3 | Date : 06/02/04
Great! I wonder what the howler has to say. Update soon!
 

fabiana
Signed | Chapter : 3 | Date : 06/02/04
First, I'd just like to say something. If you think an author deserves flaming, at least put your name on it. This way, he can come back to you and apologize or justify.

So, I'd just like to tell you, *Person-Without-A-Name*, that my betas (or me for that matter), have nothing to do with these words that looks strange in the story.

Indeed, there is a part in the chapter that has some added characters, but I think they were generated when I posted the story here, because I checked and there weren't any mistakes in file I that originally posted.

I'm trying to upload this chapter again, but now, there are some parts missing in the end when I upload it. I'm going to e-mail Nappa and notify him. I'll do my best to upload the error-free file as soon as possible.

Before that happens, I'd like to apologize for the inconvenience. But this isn't my fault, really.

And I'm really sorry if your mind,*Person-Without-A-Name*, is not open enough to accept that Harry might notice that Ginny is a girl. (Especially because I never gave a romantic connotation to it). You may be lucky in fandom and find stories where this doesn't happen, but I'm not sure this will be the case in real life.

So, good luck in it.
(And thanks for notifying).

Fabiana
 

Unsigned | Chapter : 3 | Date : 06/02/04
I really don't like that Harry's noticed that Ginny's become a "girl", nor do I like that Ginny clings to him and sobs.

Also, you might want to recheck your betas. There are some really weird words and errors in this chapter. For example:

Before Hermione could ask why, he continued, petting Buckbeak's at the same time, "I don't onk, he continued ferent, Chofferent, Choas a al date... contactme think I'll be involved with anyone for the time being," he said, eliciting Hermione to open her eyes wide.

????????????????



 

SaraMalfoy
Signed | Chapter : 3 | Date : 06/02/04
 

danielerin
Unsigned | Chapter : 3 | Date : 05/02/04
Really interesting story. It's completely plausible as a sixth book beginning (even though I know that's not necessarily what you're going for, I still think it's a compliment). The description of their reaction to the prophecy is great. (I just love Hermione!)

 

tinydancer
Signed | Chapter : 3 | Date : 05/02/04
Wonderful chapter!! Well done!
My curiosity is sooooo picked, why on earth is Dean sending Harry a Howler?! Did GInny tell him she still fancies Harry?!!

Please update
 

Drey
Unsigned | Chapter : 3 | Date : 05/02/04
Ok. You have me hooked! Now I want to know what has gotten Dean so angry at Harry that he had to send a howler to him!
 

jump   | next >>
 

Page generated in 0.00903 seconds. 250 users currently online.
Server running: Portkey Version 2, coded by James & Skinned by Imran(NAPPA).