cdanesSigned | Chapter : 1 | Date : 04/08/08
this was a really great fic. I loved the way you wrote their friendship and it had just enough normal teenage fun mixed with seriousness to seem plausible. |
| |
AnonymousUnsigned | Chapter : 1 | Date : 09/10/07
Their relationship will always be stronger, better, and much more important than any others they have! GO HARMONY! |
| |
Old ChuckUnsigned | Chapter : 1 | Date : 12/09/06
I have a hard time believing this was your first stab at writing about the Potter universe. The writing was quite mature and the interaction of the two was realistic for two basically shy individuals. I think you have nailed the behavior of genus: teenager very well.
Keep writing; it suits you well.
Old Chuck |
Author Feedback: Thanks, Chuck, your reviews are always very encouraging. Yep, I wrote this sucker on a memo pad during a plane trip to New York with my sister probably peeking over my shoulder....it's been quite a while. Thanks for reading my stuff and leaving such kind reviews! ~Ronnie |
| |
CathyDSigned | Chapter : 1 | Date : 12/09/06
Wow, love it! Great fic. I loved the game of twenty questions (even though they didn't technically finish it), and then the sweetness of the end of the fic -during their serious talk.
Great work, and I can't wait to read more from you. Keep it up!
~Cat |
Author Feedback: Thank you, I can't tell you how utterly awkward it felt to write! But I'm mostly happy with the result and happier that you left such a nice review! So thanks again! |
| |
hagridSigned | Chapter : 1 | Date : 06/06/06
I got aom'att ter say ter yeh... I great first piece of writin'! I could see em both, thats how well yer've written em. One of the finest "gettin' ter know each other" stories I've ever read. |
Author Feedback: Thanks a bunch for checking this sucker out! It was my first fic and I am therefore quite fond of it. |
| |
Tank03Signed | Chapter : 1 | Date : 22/05/06
Whew! That was heart-wrenching. You have done an incredible job with this fic. I loved all the discussion about mundane things while both were desperately trying to keep their emotions in check. I especially liked the bit at the beginning where Hermione was worried about him but she didn't want Harry to know so he wouldn't feel bad about it. That's a very touching sccene that speaks volumes about their relationship and you managed it in only one sentence. Fantastic! This so clearly explains why they are friends and why they should be more than friends.
Not that I wasn't before, but I am definitely a fan of yours now and I don't hesitate in adding you to my favorite authors list. |
Author Feedback: Oooh, thank you for adding me! I had a lot of fun writing that fic actually and exploring Harry and Hermione's relationship outside of academics and all that. And although that's not the way JKR wrote the prophecy-revealing scene, that's all right with me. Thanks so much for reviewing! |
| |
AnonymousUnsigned | Chapter : 1 | Date : 21/05/06
|
| |
|
OK, see, *that's* how I thought HBP would be. In-character and true, not a lot of bollocks and OOC-ness. (Btw, I enjoyed the small quote from 10things). I loved this piece, especially having just discovered it, and too bad you published it only days before The-Book-That-Shall-Not-Be-Named was released and depressed us all. Hopefully all will be right in the end (been working on a theory to set everything just so for almost a year now). Keep up the brilliant work at invoking the reader's emotions in such a masterful way, my heartstrings have been plucked quite a bit now (that last bit sounded a great deal more odd than what it did at first, huh?). If you want to chat about anything HP (especially H/Hr-ness), please email me; it's always such a joy to talk with a fellow shipper for Pumpkin Pie.
H&H4EVA
(Hermione) Rae |
Author Feedback:  That was the best review I've ever gotten I think! I actually wrote this while I was on a five hour plane ride to New York like...a year and a half ago? I think I scared my mom though because I had no paper and I absolutely HAD to write it down righ then. I'm sure you get those urges too, lol. I'm very flattered that you agree with what I saw as a potentially AWESOME prophecy-revealing scene and it's too bad that it didn't happen just so, but I still got the "Are you scared?" line in there! Mwahaha! Anyway, I would LOVE to chat about H/Hr shipping business and have literally no one to talk to about it! We need to all stick together, delusional or not! Besides, everything post-Hogwarts is pretty much up for grabs, hehe....Thanks again! ~Ronnie |
| |
|
I really love the story and wish that there was more but what you have is enough. I really like how it went and wish you luck as you continue to write. I also hope to be able to read bore from you also!
*%* Susanna *%* |
| |
luv4booksUnsigned | Chapter : 1 | Date : 22/12/05
wow, that was so emotional. how did you think of all those things to write , if i was JK Rowling i would pick this fic to put in the books. your a really good writer. |
Author Feedback: Wow, that's the greatest compliment I could ever hope to get as a fic writer! Thanks so much! Most of the content of this story came from the questions I often wondered while reading the books. Thanks for reviewing, and if you're interested, I just posted the first chapter to a new fic! Happy Holidays! |
| |
HayleyUnsigned | Chapter : 1 | Date : 30/09/05
Wow, great story. I love how you show the connection (no pun intended) between Harry and Hermione using a simple game of 20 questions. Brilliant. |
| |
|
Great story. Very touching. I loved hermione's little speach about refusing to fail him. Nicely done. |
| |
|
hmm i thought harry was being kind of random when he was like "wanna play 20 questions" but i thought it was a good start
ANYWAYS i liked your story (yay!) you put a lot of thought behind this, and i liked it =) keep going! |
| |
AnonymousUnsigned | Chapter : 1 | Date : 01/07/05
Hi! hey, this was great! And so well in character!  I really, really like it! great job!  15 days to go....!!!! |
Author Feedback: Hey! I'm glad you liked it! I know, I'm ridiculously excited about the book too--I've taken the day off work so that I may properly celebrate! |
| |
hammergalSigned | Chapter : 1 | Date : 01/07/05
That was really good! You really seemed to get into the minds of Harry and Hermione very well. Very good characterization. Your title was perfect because in this story they had a connection like no other. Very interesting read, it felt like a perfect prelude to their realization that they really are in love. Good job! |
Author Feedback: Thank you for your review! I really do feel that Harry and Hermione have a very strong connection in the books, but it's rather subtle because it has to contend with how their personalities are altered in the presence of Ron. I'm so glad that you enjoyed reading this! |
| |
|