BimrinSigned | Chapter : 5 | Date : 27/01/07
This is one of the few times I have openly wept at a story. The level of emotion that you were able to bring out was just amazing. I have always been on of those people that I can handle any cannon character dying except Hermione. Even Harry dying doesn't hurt me as much as Hermione dying does. She seems to be the rock for everyone. The piece that holds everyone balanced and together. |
| |
|
wow. i think i have read this about 5 times and every time i do, i cry. i love this story so much, it reminds me of a woman i knew who died a few years ago. it really touches me to know that you can write such beautiful things. thank you very much for the story, it was wonderful. |
Author Feedback: My! Thank you SO much.
You know? I have stories like that myself, stories I've read many times but still make me feel like the first time I did.
And I love them, I can SO identify what you're saying.
I'm just really touched, and flattered that for you, one of those stories is mine.
Thanks. Thank you so much, way beyond my ability to word my thanks. |
| |
|
Very beautifully done. had to keep several tissues handy while reading it. Excellant |
| |
|
Ok well I hope you know that even a robot would cry over this. I loved the end and how the children were just like their parents. After reading it it gives a sort of hope to the reader and all I can say is bravo because it was wonderful. |
| |
|
I've said it already, but this was fabulous. Thanks for writing this. Just wonderful. |
Author Feedback: aww... thanks so much!!
I wrote this for a challenge, and truth is, I'm very surprised, to this day, almost a year after I wrote it, that I was able to produce a story that was so sad!
I can't even explain what made me choose such topic for the challenge...
I laughed when you wrote that you wanted to tell them all the author didn't mean it... because I never meant to kill her! Not... as a privotal desire of mine... but I signed up for the challenge and somehow managed to pull it off... and here I am, writing more angst... *rollseyes*
So happy you liked it!
It's so nice to see people review so enthusiastically almost a year after!
Thank you so much!  |
| |
|
I've said it already, but this was fabulous. Thanks for writing this. Just wonderful. |
| |
|
This is so hard to read. The tears the tightness in my throat and the sheer suspense of not really knowing why Hermione is dying. I want to run into the story and tell them all everything will be all right and that the author was crazy and didn't mean a word of it. But this is just absolutely beautiful - there is no other word to describe this. This is the best f-----g fan fiction I've ever read. |
| |
|
This is so hard to read. The tears the tightness in my throat and the sheer suspense of not really knowing why Hermione is dying. I want to run into the story and tell them all everything will be all right and that the author was crazy and didn't mean a word of it. But this is just absolutely beautiful - there is no other word to describe this. This is the best f-----g fan fiction I've ever read. |
| |
|
The tears are still making it hard for me to read. It's still beautiful. |
| |
|
I'm having a hard time reading through the tears. This is just utterly beautiful. You know, I came here wanting to read fluff ... but this is just ...I'm glad I clicked the link. I haven't really cried over a fic in ages and ages. Beautiful ... |
| |
LaurenUnsigned | Chapter : 5 | Date : 07/07/05
That was amazing, my eyes got all teary like but in a sentimental sort of way, sad but not a bad sad. I loved this story, thanks so much for writing it!! |
| |
I'm sorry to say this but this story ripped my heart out.  That really means that you are good a the writing but I just agrivated with all the depressing stories I've been reading I know that if J.K. does not kill the three by the end of the seventh book then they will have the live that they have more than earned. |
| |
star_hh5Signed | Chapter : 5 | Date : 27/09/04
That was so sad...It was beautiful...I wonder what kind of disease Hermione got??THat was nicely written...I actually feel all the emotions you put..very descriptive...Again this is a beautiful story that makes me not take for granted my mom and dad who always has been there for me...GREAT JOB!!!!  |
Author Feedback: [QUOTE]I wonder what kind of disease Hermione got??[/QUOTE]
Yeah, me too! 
That doesn't sound very nice does it?
Thing is, I struggled for a good long while on whether or not I ought to describe Hermione's illness... This challenge was very draining for me, because it involved a lot of emotional investment... I guess that, in the end, because I had so much involved in it, emotionally speaking, I left the illness aside. Feelings were much more important...
Perhaps one day I'll go back to it, I don't know....
Thanks for your review, it makes me think that if you felt something, and take it into account for your life then I did a good job!
Thanks! |
| |
i really am bawling my eyes out when im reading this...it's kind of reminds me of when my dad died, and it's a very emotional fic....plus i hate the thought of Hermione and Harry being seperated by a death, moreso Hermione.
on the side i love it  haha, everything about it is great and i don't understand why you don't have more Reviews...  im gonna beat them with a stick....
well im outta here... |
Author Feedback: Thanks a lot!
It makes me really proud of myself to think that people if finding this emotional, because I worked extremely hard on making it exactly that!
Thanks! |
| |
Gabbychan!Unsigned | Chapter : 5 | Date : 25/09/04
wooow this is an amaaazing story really!... its very sad that is true, but its a story that made feel hope, and happiness even if hermione died.... i am amazed as how you portrayed the characters and i congratulate you for such a heartwarming, great story...! it made me cry but
it also made me feel like hermione will live forever, most important of all your story made me FEEL...whatever it was...
keep up the amazing story....! i hope that harry will stop suffering and they'll be able to meet soon.. dont get me wrong i dont want harry to die but its just i would want that to, if i lost my significant....
|
| |
|
